House roll call 311 · 92nd Congress · Dec 10, 1971
To amend H.R. 11309 by allowing presidential review of pension and other retirement plans which qualify for special tax treatment.
On Dec 10, 1971, the House voted 170–184 (HR 11309). Result: failed. By party: Democrats 33–170, Republicans 137–15. It was a split vote: the parties took opposite sides, with some members crossing over. 48 members voted against their own party.
During the 92nd Congress (1971–1972), Richard Nixon was president, and Democrats held majorities in both the House and Senate.
- Yes
- 170
- No
- 184
- Did not vote
- 88
- Date
- Dec 10, 1971
By party
- Democrats33 yes · 170 no · 55 didn’t vote
- Republicans137 yes · 15 no · 33 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- William Flynt Nichols D-AL voted yes
- Walter Flowers D-AL voted yes
- Robert Lee Fulton Sikes D-FL voted yes
- William Venroe Chappell Jr. D-FL voted yes
- James Andrew Haley D-FL voted yes
- Marvin Dawson Mathis D-GA voted yes
- Jack Thomas Brinkley D-GA voted yes
- John James Flynt Jr. D-GA voted yes
- John William Davis D-GA voted yes
- Phillip Mitchell Landrum D-GA voted yes
- Robert Grier Stephens Jr. D-GA voted yes
- Joe Skubitz R-KS voted no
- Joseph David Waggonner Jr. D-LA voted yes
- Otto Ernest Passman D-LA voted yes
- John Richard Rarick D-LA voted yes
- Silvio Ottavio Conte R-MA voted no
- Frank Bradford Morse R-MA voted no
- Goodloe Edgar Byron D-MD voted yes
- Donald Wayne Riegle Jr. R-MI voted no
- William Raleigh Hull Jr. D-MO voted yes
- Thomas Gerstle Abernethy D-MS voted yes
- Gillespie V. (Sonny) Montgomery D-MS voted yes
- William Meyers Colmer D-MS voted yes
- Walter Beaman Jones Sr. D-NC voted yes
- David Newton Henderson D-NC voted yes
- Walter Stephan Baring Jr. D-NV voted yes
- Seymour Halpern R-NY voted no
- Peter A. Peyser R-NY voted no
- Ogden Rogers Reid R-NY voted no
- Frank Jefferson Horton R-NY voted no
- Charles William Whalen Jr. R-OH voted no
- John Jarman D-OK voted yes
- Wendell Wyatt R-OR voted no
- Edward George Biester Jr. R-PA voted no
- Joseph Michael Mcdade R-PA voted no
- Robert Lawrence Coughlin R-PA voted no
- Edwin Duing Eshleman R-PA voted no
- James Robert Mann D-SC voted yes
- John Lanneau Mcmillan D-SC voted yes
- Ed Jones D-TN voted yes
- William Robert Poage D-TX voted yes
- Richard Crawford White D-TX voted yes
- Omar Truman Burleson D-TX voted yes
- George Herman Mahon D-TX voted yes
- Ovie Clark Fisher D-TX voted yes
- Thomas Nelms Downing D-VA voted yes
- Watkins Moorman Abbitt D-VA voted yes
- William Lloyd Scott R-VA voted no
How each representative voted: Yes
- William Jackson (Jack) Edwards R-AL
- William Louis Dickinson R-AL
- William Flynt Nichols D-AL
- Walter Flowers D-AL
- John Hall Buchanan Jr. R-AL
- John Paul Hammerschmidt R-AR
- John Jacob Rhodes R-AZ
- Donald Holst Clausen R-CA
- William Somers Mailliard R-CA
- Charles Samuel Gubser R-CA
- Paul Norton (Pete) Mccloskey Jr. R-CA
- Charles McKevett Teague R-CA
- Robert Bruce (Bob) Mathias R-CA
- Delwin Morgan Clawson R-CA
- John Harbin Rousselot R-CA
- Charles Edward Wiggins R-CA
- Craig Hosmer R-CA
- Jerry Lyle Pettis R-CA
- Robert Carlton (Bob) Wilson R-CA
- Donald Glenn Brotzman R-CO
- Robert Hampton Steele R-CT
- Stewart Brett Mckinney R-CT
- Pierre Samuel Du Pont IV R-DE
- Robert Lee Fulton Sikes D-FL
- William Venroe Chappell Jr. D-FL
- Louis Frey Jr. R-FL
- James Andrew Haley D-FL
- Charles William (Bill) Young R-FL
- J. Herbert Burke R-FL
- Marvin Dawson Mathis D-GA
- Jack Thomas Brinkley D-GA
- Standish Fletcher Thompson R-GA
- John James Flynt Jr. D-GA
- John William Davis D-GA
- Phillip Mitchell Landrum D-GA
- Robert Grier Stephens Jr. D-GA
- Frederick Delbert Schwengel R-IA
- Harold Royce Gross R-IA
- John Henry Kyl R-IA
- Wiley Mayne R-IA
- James Albertus Mcclure R-ID
- Orval Howard Hansen R-ID
- Harold Reginald Collier R-IL
- Robert Mcclory R-IL
- Philip Miller Crane R-IL
- John Neal Erlenborn R-IL
- John Bayard Anderson R-IL
- Leslie Cornelius Arends R-IL
- Robert Henry Michel R-IL
- Thomas Fisher Railsback R-IL
- Paul Findley R-IL
- Earl Fredrick Landgrebe R-IN
- Elwood Haynes Hillis R-IN
- William Gilmer Bray R-IN
- John Thomas Myers R-IN
- Roger Herschel Zion R-IN
- David Worth Dennis R-IN
- Keith George Sebelius R-KS
- Edward Lawrence Winn Jr. (Larry) R-KS
- Garner E. Shriver R-KS
- Marion Gene Snyder R-KY
- Tim Lee Carter R-KY
- Joseph David Waggonner Jr. D-LA
- Otto Ernest Passman D-LA
- John Richard Rarick D-LA
- Hastings Keith R-MA
- William Oswald Mills R-MD
- Lawrence Joseph Hogan R-MD
- Goodloe Edgar Byron D-MD
- Marvin Leonel Esch R-MI
- Garry Eldridge Brown R-MI
- J. Edward Hutchinson R-MI
- Gerald Rudolph Ford Jr. R-MI
- Charles Ernest Chamberlain R-MI
- James Harvey R-MI
- Guy Adrian Vander Jagt R-MI
- Elford Albin Cederberg R-MI
- Philip Edward Ruppe R-MI
- William S. Broomfield R-MI
- Jack H. Mcdonald R-MI
- Albert Harold Quie R-MN
- Ancher Nelsen R-MN
- William Eldridge Frenzel R-MN
- John Matthew Zwach R-MN
- William Raleigh Hull Jr. D-MO
- Durward Gorham Hall R-MO
- Thomas Gerstle Abernethy D-MS
- Gillespie V. (Sonny) Montgomery D-MS
- William Meyers Colmer D-MS
- Richard Gardner (Dick) Shoup R-MT
- Walter Beaman Jones Sr. D-NC
- David Newton Henderson D-NC
- Wilmer David (Vinegar Bend) Mizell R-NC
- Earl Baker Ruth R-NC
- Charles Raper Jonas R-NC
- James Thomas Broyhill R-NC
- Mark Andrews R-ND
- Charles Thone R-NE
- John Yetter Mccollister R-NE
- Louis Crosby Wyman R-NH
- James Colgate Cleveland R-NH
- John Edmund Hunt R-NJ
- Charles William Sandman Jr. R-NJ
- Peter Hood Ballantine Frelinghuysen Jr. R-NJ
- Edwin Bell Forsythe R-NJ
- William Beck Widnall R-NJ
- Florence Price Dwyer R-NJ
- Walter Stephan Baring Jr. D-NV
- James Russell Grover Jr. R-NY
- John Waldemar Wydler R-NY
- Norman Frederick Lent R-NY
- Hamilton Fish Jr. R-NY
- Carleton James King R-NY
- Robert Cameron Mcewen R-NY
- Alexander Pirnie R-NY
- Howard Winfield Robison R-NY
- John Hart Terry R-NY
- Barber Benjamin Conable Jr. R-NY
- James Fred Hastings R-NY
- Jack French Kemp R-NY
- Henry P. Smith III R-NY
- William John Keating R-OH
- Donald Daniel Clancy R-OH
- William Moore Mcculloch R-OH
- Delbert Leroy Latta R-OH
- William Howard Harsha R-OH
- Clarence J. Brown Jr. R-OH
- Jackson Edward Betts R-OH
- Clarence E. Miller R-OH
- John William Stanton R-OH
- Samuel Leeper Devine R-OH
- Charles Adams Mosher R-OH
- Chalmers Pangburn Wylie R-OH
- John Jarman D-OK
- John Newbold Happy Camp R-OK
- John Richard Dellenback R-OR
- Lawrence Gordon Williams R-PA
- John Haines Ware III R-PA
- Herman Theodore Schneebeli R-PA
- Henry John Heinz III R-PA
- George Atlee Goodling R-PA
- John Phillips Saylor R-PA
- Albert Walter Johnson R-PA
- James Robert Mann D-SC
- John Lanneau Mcmillan D-SC
- James Henry Quillen R-TN
- John James Duncan R-TN
- LaMar Baker R-TN
- Ed Jones D-TN
- James Mitchell Collins R-TX
- William Reynolds Archer Jr. R-TX
- William Robert Poage D-TX
- Richard Crawford White D-TX
- Omar Truman Burleson D-TX
- Robert Dale Price R-TX
- George Herman Mahon D-TX
- Ovie Clark Fisher D-TX
- Thomas Nelms Downing D-VA
- George William Whitehurst R-VA
- Watkins Moorman Abbitt D-VA
- Richard Harding Poff R-VA
- James Kenneth Robinson R-VA
- William Creed Wampler R-VA
- Joel Thomas Broyhill R-VA
- Thomas Minor Pelly R-WA
- Vernon Wallace Thomson R-WI
- William Albert Steiger R-WI
- John William Byrnes R-WI
- Glenn Robert Davis R-WI
- Alvin Edward O'Konski R-WI
How each representative voted: No
- Nicholas Joseph Begich D-AK
- Tom Bevill D-AL
- Robert Emmett Jones Jr. D-AL
- William Vollie (Bill) Alexander Jr. D-AR
- Harold Terry Johnson D-CA
- John Emerson Moss D-CA
- Robert Louis Leggett D-CA
- Phillip Burton D-CA
- Ronald V. Dellums D-CA
- George Paul Miller D-CA
- William Donlon (Don) Edwards D-CA
- Jerome Russell Waldie D-CA
- John Joseph Mcfall D-CA
- Bernice Frederic Sisk D-CA
- Glenn Malcolm Anderson D-CA
- Chester Earl Holifield D-CA
- Thomas Mankell Rees D-CA
- George Elmore Danielson D-CA
- Edward R. Roybal D-CA
- Richard Thomas Hanna D-CA
- Wayne Norviel Aspinall D-CO
- William Ross Cotter D-CT
- Robert Nicholas Giaimo D-CT
- John Stephen Monagan D-CT
- Ella Tambussi Grasso D-CT
- Charles Edward Bennett D-FL
- Paul Grant Rogers D-FL
- Claude Denson Pepper D-FL
- Dante Bruno Fascell D-FL
- George Elliott Hagan D-GA
- Williamson Sylvester Stuckey Jr. D-GA
- Spark Masayuki Matsunaga D-HI
- John Chester Culver D-IA
- Neal Edward Smith D-IA
- Abner Joseph Mikva D-IL
- Morgan Francis Murphy D-IL
- Sidney Richard Yates D-IL
- Roman Conrad Pucinski D-IL
- Kenneth James Gray D-IL
- George Edward Shipley D-IL
- Charles Melvin Price D-IL
- Ray John Madden D-IN
- John Brademas D-IN
- Lee Herbert Hamilton D-IN
- Andrew Jacobs Jr. D-IN
- William Robert Roy D-KS
- Joe Skubitz R-KS
- Frank Albert Stubblefield D-KY
- William Huston Natcher D-KY
- Romano Louis Mazzoli D-KY
- William Prather Curlin Jr. D-KY
- Carl Dewey Perkins D-KY
- Thomas Hale Boggs Sr. D-LA
- Patrick Thomson Caffery D-LA
- Speedy Oteria Long D-LA
- Silvio Ottavio Conte R-MA
- Edward Patrick Boland D-MA
- Robert Frederick Drinan D-MA
- Harold Daniel Donohue D-MA
- Frank Bradford Morse R-MA
- Michael Joseph Harrington D-MA
- Torbert Hart Macdonald D-MA
- Thomas Philip (Tip) O'Neill Jr. D-MA
- Louise Day Hicks D-MA
- James Anthony Burke D-MA
- Clarence Dickinson Long D-MD
- Edward Alexander Garmatz D-MD
- Paul Spyros Sarbanes D-MD
- Parren James Mitchell D-MD
- Peter Nicholas Kyros D-ME
- William Dodd Hathaway D-ME
- Donald Wayne Riegle Jr. R-MI
- James Grant O'Hara D-MI
- Lucien Norbert Nedzi D-MI
- William David Ford D-MI
- John David Dingell Jr. D-MI
- Joseph Edward Karth D-MN
- Donald MacKay Fraser D-MN
- Robert Selmer Bergland D-MN
- James Wadsworth Symington D-MO
- William Joseph Randall D-MO
- Richard Walker Bolling D-MO
- Richard Howard Ichord II D-MO
- William Leonard Hungate D-MO
- Bill D. Burlison D-MO
- Jamie Lloyd Whitten D-MS
- Charles Hudson Griffin D-MS
- John Melcher D-MT
- Lawrence H. Fountain D-NC
- Lunsford Richardson Preyer D-NC
- Alton Asa Lennon D-NC
- Roy Arthur Taylor D-NC
- Arthur Albert Link D-ND
- James John Howard D-NJ
- Frank Thompson Jr. D-NJ
- Robert A. Roe D-NJ
- Henry Helstoski D-NJ
- Peter Wallace Rodino Jr. D-NJ
- Joseph George Minish D-NJ
- Cornelius Edward Gallagher D-NJ
- Dominick Vincent Daniels D-NJ
- Edward James Patten D-NJ
- Otis Grey Pike D-NY
- Lester Lionel Wolff D-NY
- Seymour Halpern R-NY
- Joseph Patrick Addabbo D-NY
- Benjamin Stanley Rosenthal D-NY
- James Joseph Delaney D-NY
- Frank James Brasco D-NY
- Shirley Anita Chisholm D-NY
- Bertram L. Podell D-NY
- John James Rooney D-NY
- Hugh Leo Carey D-NY
- Edward Irving Koch D-NY
- Bella Savitzky Abzug D-NY
- William Fitts Ryan D-NY
- Herman Badillo D-NY
- James Haas Scheuer D-NY
- Jonathan Brewster Bingham D-NY
- Mario Biaggi D-NY
- Peter A. Peyser R-NY
- Ogden Rogers Reid R-NY
- John Goodchild Dow D-NY
- Samuel Studdiford Stratton D-NY
- Frank Jefferson Horton R-NY
- Thaddeus Joseph Dulski D-NY
- Charles William Whalen Jr. R-OH
- Thomas William Ludlow Ashley D-OH
- John Frederick Seiberling D-OH
- Charles Joseph Carney D-OH
- Charles Albert Vanik D-OH
- Carl Bert Albert D-OK
- Wendell Wyatt R-OR
- Albert Conrad Ullman D-OR
- Edith Starrett Green D-OR
- William Aloysius Barrett D-PA
- Robert Nelson Cornelius Nix Sr. D-PA
- James Aloysius Byrne D-PA
- William Joseph Green D-PA
- Gus Yatron D-PA
- Edward George Biester Jr. R-PA
- Joseph Michael Mcdade R-PA
- Robert Lawrence Coughlin R-PA
- William Singer Moorhead D-PA
- Frederick Bernard Rooney D-PA
- Edwin Duing Eshleman R-PA
- Joseph Matthew Gaydos D-PA
- John Herman Dent D-PA
- Joseph Phillip Vigorito D-PA
- Frank Monroe Clark D-PA
- Thomas Ellsworth Morgan D-PA
- Fernand Joseph St. Germain D-RI
- Mendel Jackson Davis D-SC
- William Jennings Bryan Dorn D-SC
- Thomas Smithwick Gettys D-SC
- Frank Edward Denholm D-SD
- James George Abourezk D-SD
- William Robert Anderson D-TN
- John William Wright Patman D-TX
- Herbert Ray Roberts D-TX
- Earle Cabell D-TX
- Jack Bascom Brooks D-TX
- James Jarrell (Jake) Pickle D-TX
- Graham Boynton Purcell Jr. D-TX
- John Andrew Young D-TX
- Eligio De La Garza II (Kika) D-TX
- Henry B. González D-TX
- Robert Randolph Casey D-TX
- Abraham Kazen Jr. D-TX
- Koln Gunn Mckay D-UT
- David Edward Satterfield III D-VA
- Wilbur Clarence (Dan) Daniel D-VA
- William Lloyd Scott R-VA
- Edwin Lloyd Meeds D-WA
- Julia Butler Hansen D-WA
- Mike Mccormack D-WA
- Brockman (Brock) Adams D-WA
- Leslie Aspin D-WI
- Robert William Kastenmeier D-WI
- Clement John Zablocki D-WI
- David Ross Obey D-WI
- Harley Orrin Staggers D-WV
- John Mark Slack Jr. D-WV
- Kenneth William Hechler D-WV
- James Kee D-WV
Did not vote
- Elizabeth Bullock Andrews D-AL
- George William Andrews D-AL
- Wilbur Daigh Mills D-AR
- David Hampton Pryor D-AR
- Morris King Udall D-AZ
- Sam Steiger R-AZ
- Burt Lacklen Talcott R-CA
- H. Allen Smith R-CA
- Augustus Freeman (Gus) Hawkins D-CA
- James Charles Corman D-CA
- Barry Morris Goldwater Jr. R-CA
- Alphonzo Bell R-CA
- Charles Herbert Wilson D-CA
- John George Schmitz R-CA
- Lionel Van Deerlin D-CA
- Victor Vincent Veysey R-CA
- James Douglas (Mike) Mckevitt R-CO
- Frank Edward Evans D-CO
- Don Fuqua D-FL
- Sam Melville Gibbons D-FL
- Benjamin Bentley Blackburn R-GA
- Patsy Takemoto Mink D-HI
- William Joseph Scherle R-IA
- Ralph Harold Metcalfe D-IL
- Edward Joseph Derwinski R-IL
- John Carl Kluczynski D-IL
- George Washington Collins D-IL
- Frank Annunzio D-IL
- Daniel David Rostenkowski D-IL
- Charlotte Thompson Reid R-IL
- Cliffard Dale Carlson R-IL
- William Lee Springer R-IL
- John Edward Roush D-IN
- John Clarence Watts D-KY
- Felix Edward Hébert D-LA
- Edwin Washington Edwards D-LA
- John Berlinger Breaux D-LA
- Margaret M. Heckler R-MA
- Rogers Clark Ballard Morton R-MD
- Gilbert Gude R-MD
- John Conyers Jr. D-MI
- Charles Coles Diggs Jr. D-MI
- Martha Wright Griffiths D-MI
- John Anton Blatnik D-MN
- William Lacy Clay Sr. D-MO
- Leonor Kretzer Sullivan D-MO
- Nick Galifianakis D-NC
- David Thomas Martin R-NE
- Manuel Luján Jr. R-NM
- Harold Lowell Runnels D-NM
- Emanuel Celler D-NY
- John Michael Murphy D-NY
- Charles B. Rangel D-NY
- James Michael Hanley D-NY
- Frank Townsend Bow R-OH
- John Milan Ashbrook R-OH
- Wayne Levere Hays D-OH
- James Vincent Stanton D-OH
- Louis Stokes D-OH
- William Edwin Minshall Jr. R-OH
- Walter Eugene Powell R-OH
- Page Henry Belcher R-OK
- Edmond Augustus Edmondson D-OK
- Thomas Jefferson Steed D-OK
- Joshua Eilberg D-PA
- Daniel John Flood D-PA
- John Irving Whalley R-PA
- Robert James Corbett R-PA
- James Grove Fulton R-PA
- William Sheldrick Conover II R-PA
- Robert Owens Tiernan D-RI
- Floyd Davidson Spence R-SC
- Joseph Landon Evins D-TN
- Richard Harmon Fulton D-TN
- Leonard Ray Blanton D-TN
- Dan Heflin Kuykendall R-TN
- John Vernard Dowdy D-TX
- Olin Earl Teague D-TX
- Robert Christian Eckhardt D-TX
- James Claude Wright Jr. D-TX
- Sherman Parkinson Lloyd R-UT
- Richard Walker Mallary R-VT
- Robert Theodore Stafford R-VT
- Thomas Stephen Foley D-WA
- Floyd Verne Hicks D-WA
- Henry Schoellkopf Reuss D-WI
- Robert Homer Mollohan D-WV
- Teno Roncalio D-WY
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To amend H.R. 11309 by allowing presidential…: House Vote, Dec 10…,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/92-H-311/to-amend-h-r-11309-by-allowing-presidential-review (accessed 2026-10-17).