House roll call 177 · 91st Congress · Dec 23, 1969
To recede from disagreement with Senate amendment 33 to H.R. 15209, which would limit the application of the so-called philadelphia plan.
On Dec 23, 1969, the House voted 156–208 (HR 15209). Result: failed. By party: Democrats 119–90, Republicans 41–126. It was a split vote: the parties took opposite sides, with some members crossing over. 131 members voted against their own party.
During the 91st Congress (1969–1970), Richard Nixon was president, and Democrats held majorities in both the House and Senate.
- Yes
- 156
- No
- 208
- Did not vote
- 73
- Date
- Dec 23, 1969
By party
- Republicans41 yes · 126 no · 32 didn’t vote
- Democrats119 yes · 90 no · 41 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- George William Andrews D-AL voted no
- Tom Bevill D-AL voted no
- Morris King Udall D-AZ voted no
- Sam Steiger R-AZ voted yes
- Robert Louis Leggett D-CA voted no
- Phillip Burton D-CA voted no
- Jeffery Cohelan D-CA voted no
- Jerome Russell Waldie D-CA voted no
- Glenn Malcolm Anderson D-CA voted no
- Augustus Freeman (Gus) Hawkins D-CA voted no
- James Charles Corman D-CA voted no
- Delwin Morgan Clawson R-CA voted yes
- Charles Edward Wiggins R-CA voted yes
- Edward R. Roybal D-CA voted no
- Charles Herbert Wilson D-CA voted no
- Richard Thomas Hanna D-CA voted no
- Lionel Van Deerlin D-CA voted no
- John Varick Tunney D-CA voted no
- Byron Giles Rogers D-CO voted no
- Frank Edward Evans D-CO voted no
- Emilio Quincy Daddario D-CT voted no
- Louis Frey Jr. R-FL voted yes
- Sam Melville Gibbons D-FL voted no
- William Cato Cramer R-FL voted yes
- Benjamin Bentley Blackburn R-GA voted yes
- Standish Fletcher Thompson R-GA voted yes
- Patsy Takemoto Mink D-HI voted no
- Spark Masayuki Matsunaga D-HI voted no
- John Chester Culver D-IA voted no
- Harold Royce Gross R-IA voted yes
- William Joseph Scherle R-IA voted yes
- Abner Joseph Mikva D-IL voted no
- Edward Joseph Derwinski R-IL voted yes
- Frank Annunzio D-IL voted no
- Sidney Richard Yates D-IL voted no
- Philip Miller Crane R-IL voted yes
- Charles Melvin Price D-IL voted no
- Ray John Madden D-IN voted no
- John Brademas D-IN voted no
- Richard Lowell Roudebush R-IN voted yes
- William Gilmer Bray R-IN voted yes
- John Thomas Myers R-IN voted yes
- Lee Herbert Hamilton D-IN voted no
- Andrew Jacobs Jr. D-IN voted no
- Marion Gene Snyder R-KY voted yes
- Thomas Hale Boggs Sr. D-LA voted no
- Edward Patrick Boland D-MA voted no
- Michael Joseph Harrington D-MA voted no
- Thomas Philip (Tip) O'Neill Jr. D-MA voted no
- Edward Alexander Garmatz D-MD voted no
- Samuel Nathaniel Friedel D-MD voted no
- William Dodd Hathaway D-ME voted no
- John Conyers Jr. D-MI voted no
- Charles Coles Diggs Jr. D-MI voted no
- Jack H. Mcdonald R-MI voted yes
- Donald MacKay Fraser D-MN voted no
- John Anton Blatnik D-MN voted no
- William Lacy Clay Sr. D-MO voted no
- Wilmer David (Vinegar Bend) Mizell R-NC voted yes
- Earl Baker Ruth R-NC voted yes
- Charles Raper Jonas R-NC voted yes
- James Thomas Broyhill R-NC voted yes
- Robert Vernon Denney R-NE voted yes
- James John Howard D-NJ voted no
- Frank Thompson Jr. D-NJ voted no
- Henry Helstoski D-NJ voted no
- Peter Wallace Rodino Jr. D-NJ voted no
- Joseph George Minish D-NJ voted no
- Cornelius Edward Gallagher D-NJ voted no
- Edward James Patten D-NJ voted no
- Edgar Franklin Foreman R-NM voted yes
- Otis Grey Pike D-NY voted no
- James Russell Grover Jr. R-NY voted yes
- Allard Kenneth Lowenstein D-NY voted no
- Benjamin Stanley Rosenthal D-NY voted no
- Emanuel Celler D-NY voted no
- Frank James Brasco D-NY voted no
- Shirley Anita Chisholm D-NY voted no
- Bertram L. Podell D-NY voted no
- John James Rooney D-NY voted no
And 51 more.
The bill
How each representative voted: Yes
- William Flynt Nichols D-AL
- Walter Flowers D-AL
- Robert Emmett Jones Jr. D-AL
- William Vollie (Bill) Alexander Jr. D-AR
- David Hampton Pryor D-AR
- Sam Steiger R-AZ
- Harold Terry Johnson D-CA
- John Joseph Mcfall D-CA
- Chester Earl Holifield D-CA
- Delwin Morgan Clawson R-CA
- Charles Edward Wiggins R-CA
- George Edward Brown Jr. D-CA
- William Leon St. Onge D-CT
- Robert Nicholas Giaimo D-CT
- John Stephen Monagan D-CT
- Don Fuqua D-FL
- Charles Edward Bennett D-FL
- William Venroe Chappell Jr. D-FL
- Louis Frey Jr. R-FL
- James Andrew Haley D-FL
- William Cato Cramer R-FL
- Paul Grant Rogers D-FL
- Claude Denson Pepper D-FL
- George Elliott Hagan D-GA
- Maston Emmett O'Neal Jr. D-GA
- Jack Thomas Brinkley D-GA
- Benjamin Bentley Blackburn R-GA
- Standish Fletcher Thompson R-GA
- John James Flynt Jr. D-GA
- John William Davis D-GA
- Williamson Sylvester Stuckey Jr. D-GA
- Harold Royce Gross R-IA
- Neal Edward Smith D-IA
- William Joseph Scherle R-IA
- William Thomas Murphy D-IL
- Edward Joseph Derwinski R-IL
- John Carl Kluczynski D-IL
- Roman Conrad Pucinski D-IL
- Philip Miller Crane R-IL
- Kenneth James Gray D-IL
- George Edward Shipley D-IL
- Richard Lowell Roudebush R-IN
- William Gilmer Bray R-IN
- John Thomas Myers R-IN
- Frank Albert Stubblefield D-KY
- William Huston Natcher D-KY
- Marion Gene Snyder R-KY
- John Clarence Watts D-KY
- Carl Dewey Perkins D-KY
- Felix Edward Hébert D-LA
- Joseph David Waggonner Jr. D-LA
- Otto Ernest Passman D-LA
- John Richard Rarick D-LA
- Speedy Oteria Long D-LA
- Philip Joseph Philbin D-MA
- Harold Daniel Donohue D-MA
- Torbert Hart Macdonald D-MA
- James Anthony Burke D-MA
- Clarence Dickinson Long D-MD
- Peter Nicholas Kyros D-ME
- James Grant O'Hara D-MI
- Lucien Norbert Nedzi D-MI
- William David Ford D-MI
- John David Dingell Jr. D-MI
- Jack H. Mcdonald R-MI
- Joseph Edward Karth D-MN
- James Wadsworth Symington D-MO
- William Joseph Randall D-MO
- Richard Howard Ichord II D-MO
- William Leonard Hungate D-MO
- Bill D. Burlison D-MO
- Thomas Gerstle Abernethy D-MS
- Jamie Lloyd Whitten D-MS
- Charles Hudson Griffin D-MS
- Gillespie V. (Sonny) Montgomery D-MS
- Arnold Olsen D-MT
- John Melcher D-MT
- Walter Beaman Jones Sr. D-NC
- Lawrence H. Fountain D-NC
- David Newton Henderson D-NC
- Nick Galifianakis D-NC
- Wilmer David (Vinegar Bend) Mizell R-NC
- Lunsford Richardson Preyer D-NC
- Alton Asa Lennon D-NC
- Earl Baker Ruth R-NC
- Charles Raper Jonas R-NC
- James Thomas Broyhill R-NC
- Roy Arthur Taylor D-NC
- Robert Vernon Denney R-NE
- Robert A. Roe D-NJ
- Dominick Vincent Daniels D-NJ
- Edgar Franklin Foreman R-NM
- Walter Stephan Baring Jr. D-NV
- James Russell Grover Jr. R-NY
- Joseph Patrick Addabbo D-NY
- Mario Biaggi D-NY
- Carleton James King R-NY
- Donald Daniel Clancy R-OH
- William Howard Harsha R-OH
- Samuel Leeper Devine R-OH
- John Milan Ashbrook R-OH
- Wayne Levere Hays D-OH
- William Edwin Minshall Jr. R-OH
- Edmond Augustus Edmondson D-OK
- Thomas Jefferson Steed D-OK
- John Jarman D-OK
- Albert Conrad Ullman D-OR
- Joshua Eilberg D-PA
- Gus Yatron D-PA
- Lawrence Gordon Williams R-PA
- Daniel John Flood D-PA
- Frederick Bernard Rooney D-PA
- Robert James Corbett R-PA
- Joseph Matthew Gaydos D-PA
- Joseph Phillip Vigorito D-PA
- Frank Monroe Clark D-PA
- Thomas Ellsworth Morgan D-PA
- James Grove Fulton R-PA
- Fernand Joseph St. Germain D-RI
- Robert Owens Tiernan D-RI
- Lucius Mendel Rivers D-SC
- Albert William Watson R-SC
- William Jennings Bryan Dorn D-SC
- James Robert Mann D-SC
- Thomas Smithwick Gettys D-SC
- John Lanneau Mcmillan D-SC
- James Henry Quillen R-TN
- John James Duncan R-TN
- William Robert Anderson D-TN
- Ed Jones D-TN
- John William Wright Patman D-TX
- John Vernard Dowdy D-TX
- James Mitchell Collins R-TX
- Herbert Ray Roberts D-TX
- Earle Cabell D-TX
- Jack Bascom Brooks D-TX
- James Jarrell (Jake) Pickle D-TX
- Graham Boynton Purcell Jr. D-TX
- John Andrew Young D-TX
- Eligio De La Garza II (Kika) D-TX
- Omar Truman Burleson D-TX
- George Herman Mahon D-TX
- Ovie Clark Fisher D-TX
- Robert Randolph Casey D-TX
- Abraham Kazen Jr. D-TX
- Thomas Nelms Downing D-VA
- George William Whitehurst R-VA
- David Edward Satterfield III D-VA
- Wilbur Clarence (Dan) Daniel D-VA
- John Otho Marsh Jr. D-VA
- William Lloyd Scott R-VA
- William Creed Wampler R-VA
- Joel Thomas Broyhill R-VA
- Julia Butler Hansen D-WA
- Floyd Verne Hicks D-WA
- Clement John Zablocki D-WI
- Alvin Edward O'Konski R-WI
- Robert Homer Mollohan D-WV
- John Mark Slack Jr. D-WV
- James Kee D-WV
How each representative voted: No
- Howard Wallace Pollock R-AK
- William Jackson (Jack) Edwards R-AL
- William Louis Dickinson R-AL
- George William Andrews D-AL
- John Hall Buchanan Jr. R-AL
- Tom Bevill D-AL
- John Paul Hammerschmidt R-AR
- John Jacob Rhodes R-AZ
- Morris King Udall D-AZ
- Donald Holst Clausen R-CA
- Robert Louis Leggett D-CA
- Phillip Burton D-CA
- William Somers Mailliard R-CA
- Jeffery Cohelan D-CA
- Charles Samuel Gubser R-CA
- Paul Norton (Pete) Mccloskey Jr. R-CA
- Burt Lacklen Talcott R-CA
- Charles McKevett Teague R-CA
- Jerome Russell Waldie D-CA
- Glenn Malcolm Anderson D-CA
- Robert Bruce (Bob) Mathias R-CA
- Augustus Freeman (Gus) Hawkins D-CA
- James Charles Corman D-CA
- Alphonzo Bell R-CA
- Edward R. Roybal D-CA
- Charles Herbert Wilson D-CA
- Craig Hosmer R-CA
- Jerry Lyle Pettis R-CA
- Richard Thomas Hanna D-CA
- James Boyd Utt R-CA
- Robert Carlton (Bob) Wilson R-CA
- Lionel Van Deerlin D-CA
- John Varick Tunney D-CA
- Byron Giles Rogers D-CO
- Donald Glenn Brotzman R-CO
- Frank Edward Evans D-CO
- Emilio Quincy Daddario D-CT
- Lowell Palmer Weicker Jr. R-CT
- Thomas Joseph Meskill R-CT
- William Victor Roth Jr. R-DE
- Sam Melville Gibbons D-FL
- J. Herbert Burke R-FL
- Patsy Takemoto Mink D-HI
- Spark Masayuki Matsunaga D-HI
- Frederick Delbert Schwengel R-IA
- John Chester Culver D-IA
- John Henry Kyl R-IA
- Wiley Mayne R-IA
- James Albertus Mcclure R-ID
- Orval Howard Hansen R-ID
- Abner Joseph Mikva D-IL
- Frank Annunzio D-IL
- Sidney Richard Yates D-IL
- John Neal Erlenborn R-IL
- Charlotte Thompson Reid R-IL
- John Bayard Anderson R-IL
- Leslie Cornelius Arends R-IL
- Robert Henry Michel R-IL
- Thomas Fisher Railsback R-IL
- William Lee Springer R-IL
- Charles Melvin Price D-IL
- Ray John Madden D-IN
- Earl Fredrick Landgrebe R-IN
- John Brademas D-IN
- Roger Herschel Zion R-IN
- Lee Herbert Hamilton D-IN
- David Worth Dennis R-IN
- Andrew Jacobs Jr. D-IN
- Keith George Sebelius R-KS
- Chester Louis Mize R-KS
- Edward Lawrence Winn Jr. (Larry) R-KS
- Garner E. Shriver R-KS
- William Owen Cowger R-KY
- Tim Lee Carter R-KY
- Thomas Hale Boggs Sr. D-LA
- Silvio Ottavio Conte R-MA
- Edward Patrick Boland D-MA
- Michael Joseph Harrington D-MA
- Thomas Philip (Tip) O'Neill Jr. D-MA
- Margaret M. Heckler R-MA
- Hastings Keith R-MA
- Rogers Clark Ballard Morton R-MD
- Edward Alexander Garmatz D-MD
- Lawrence Joseph Hogan R-MD
- John Glenn Beall Jr. R-MD
- Samuel Nathaniel Friedel D-MD
- Gilbert Gude R-MD
- William Dodd Hathaway D-ME
- John Conyers Jr. D-MI
- Marvin Leonel Esch R-MI
- Garry Eldridge Brown R-MI
- J. Edward Hutchinson R-MI
- Gerald Rudolph Ford Jr. R-MI
- Charles Ernest Chamberlain R-MI
- Donald Wayne Riegle Jr. R-MI
- Guy Adrian Vander Jagt R-MI
- Elford Albin Cederberg R-MI
- Philip Edward Ruppe R-MI
- Charles Coles Diggs Jr. D-MI
- William S. Broomfield R-MI
- Albert Harold Quie R-MN
- Ancher Nelsen R-MN
- Clark Macgregor R-MN
- Donald MacKay Fraser D-MN
- John Matthew Zwach R-MN
- Odin Elsford Stanley Langen R-MN
- John Anton Blatnik D-MN
- William Lacy Clay Sr. D-MO
- Thomas Savig Kleppe R-ND
- Glenn Clarence Cunningham R-NE
- Louis Crosby Wyman R-NH
- James Colgate Cleveland R-NH
- John Edmund Hunt R-NJ
- Charles William Sandman Jr. R-NJ
- James John Howard D-NJ
- Frank Thompson Jr. D-NJ
- Peter Hood Ballantine Frelinghuysen Jr. R-NJ
- William Beck Widnall R-NJ
- Henry Helstoski D-NJ
- Peter Wallace Rodino Jr. D-NJ
- Joseph George Minish D-NJ
- Cornelius Edward Gallagher D-NJ
- Edward James Patten D-NJ
- Manuel Luján Jr. R-NM
- Otis Grey Pike D-NY
- John Waldemar Wydler R-NY
- Allard Kenneth Lowenstein D-NY
- Seymour Halpern R-NY
- Benjamin Stanley Rosenthal D-NY
- Emanuel Celler D-NY
- Frank James Brasco D-NY
- Shirley Anita Chisholm D-NY
- Bertram L. Podell D-NY
- John James Rooney D-NY
- John Michael Murphy D-NY
- Edward Irving Koch D-NY
- Leonard Farbstein D-NY
- William Fitts Ryan D-NY
- James Haas Scheuer D-NY
- Jacob H. Gilbert D-NY
- Jonathan Brewster Bingham D-NY
- Richard Lawrence Ottinger D-NY
- Ogden Rogers Reid R-NY
- Martin Boswell Mckneally R-NY
- Hamilton Fish Jr. R-NY
- Daniel Evan Button R-NY
- Robert Cameron Mcewen R-NY
- Alexander Pirnie R-NY
- Howard Winfield Robison R-NY
- James Michael Hanley D-NY
- Samuel Studdiford Stratton D-NY
- Frank Jefferson Horton R-NY
- Barber Benjamin Conable Jr. R-NY
- James Fred Hastings R-NY
- Richard Dean Mccarthy D-NY
- Henry P. Smith III R-NY
- Thaddeus Joseph Dulski D-NY
- Robert Taft Jr. R-OH
- Charles William Whalen Jr. R-OH
- William Moore Mcculloch R-OH
- Delbert Leroy Latta R-OH
- Clarence J. Brown Jr. R-OH
- Jackson Edward Betts R-OH
- Thomas William Ludlow Ashley D-OH
- Clarence E. Miller R-OH
- John William Stanton R-OH
- Charles Adams Mosher R-OH
- William Hanes Ayres R-OH
- Chalmers Pangburn Wylie R-OH
- Frank Townsend Bow R-OH
- Michael Aloysius Feighan D-OH
- Louis Stokes D-OH
- Charles Albert Vanik D-OH
- Donald Edgar Lukens R-OH
- Page Henry Belcher R-OK
- Carl Bert Albert D-OK
- John Newbold Happy Camp R-OK
- Wendell Wyatt R-OR
- John Richard Dellenback R-OR
- William Aloysius Barrett D-PA
- Robert Nelson Cornelius Nix Sr. D-PA
- James Aloysius Byrne D-PA
- William Joseph Green D-PA
- Edward George Biester Jr. R-PA
- Joseph Michael Mcdade R-PA
- John Irving Whalley R-PA
- Robert Lawrence Coughlin R-PA
- William Singer Moorhead D-PA
- Edwin Duing Eshleman R-PA
- Herman Theodore Schneebeli R-PA
- George Atlee Goodling R-PA
- John Phillips Saylor R-PA
- Dan Heflin Kuykendall R-TN
- George Herbert Walker Bush R-TX
- Robert Christian Eckhardt D-TX
- Richard Crawford White D-TX
- Robert Dale Price R-TX
- Henry B. González D-TX
- Sherman Parkinson Lloyd R-UT
- Robert Theodore Stafford R-VT
- Thomas Minor Pelly R-WA
- Edwin Lloyd Meeds D-WA
- Catherine Dean May R-WA
- Thomas Stephen Foley D-WA
- Brockman (Brock) Adams D-WA
- Henry Carl Schadeberg R-WI
- Robert William Kastenmeier D-WI
- Vernon Wallace Thomson R-WI
- Henry Schoellkopf Reuss D-WI
- William Albert Steiger R-WI
- David Ross Obey D-WI
- John William Byrnes R-WI
- Glenn Robert Davis R-WI
- Harley Orrin Staggers D-WV
- Kenneth William Hechler D-WV
- John Schiller Wold R-WY
Did not vote
- Wilbur Daigh Mills D-AR
- John Emerson Moss D-CA
- George Paul Miller D-CA
- William Donlon (Don) Edwards D-CA
- Bernice Frederic Sisk D-CA
- H. Allen Smith R-CA
- Glenard Paul Lipscomb R-CA
- John Harbin Rousselot R-CA
- Thomas Mankell Rees D-CA
- Barry Morris Goldwater Jr. R-CA
- Edwin Reinecke R-CA
- John George Schmitz R-CA
- Wayne Norviel Aspinall D-CO
- Robert Hampton Steele R-CT
- Robert Lee Fulton Sikes D-FL
- Dante Bruno Fascell D-FL
- Phillip Mitchell Landrum D-GA
- Robert Grier Stephens Jr. D-GA
- William Levi Dawson D-IL
- Daniel John Ronan D-IL
- George Washington Collins D-IL
- Daniel David Rostenkowski D-IL
- Harold Reginald Collier R-IL
- Robert Mcclory R-IL
- Donald Henry Rumsfeld R-IL
- Paul Findley R-IL
- Edwin Ross Adair R-IN
- Joe Skubitz R-KS
- Patrick Thomson Caffery D-LA
- Edwin Washington Edwards D-LA
- Frank Bradford Morse R-MA
- William Henry Bates R-MA
- John William Mccormack D-MA
- George Hyde Fallon D-MD
- James Harvey R-MI
- Martha Wright Griffiths D-MI
- Leonor Kretzer Sullivan D-MO
- Richard Walker Bolling D-MO
- William Raleigh Hull Jr. D-MO
- Durward Gorham Hall R-MO
- William Meyers Colmer D-MS
- James Franklin Battin R-MT
- Mark Andrews R-ND
- David Thomas Martin R-NE
- Edwin Bell Forsythe R-NJ
- William Thomas Cahill R-NJ
- Charles Samuel Joelson D-NJ
- Florence Price Dwyer R-NJ
- Lester Lionel Wolff D-NY
- James Joseph Delaney D-NY
- Hugh Leo Carey D-NY
- Adam Clayton Powell Jr. D-NY
- Charles Joseph Carney D-OH
- Michael Joseph Kirwan D-OH
- Edith Starrett Green D-OR
- George Robert Watkins R-PA
- John Haines Ware III R-PA
- John Herman Dent D-PA
- Albert Walter Johnson R-PA
- Benjamin Reifel R-SD
- Ellis Yarnal Berry R-SD
- William Emerson Brock III R-TN
- Joseph Landon Evins D-TN
- Richard Harmon Fulton D-TN
- Leonard Ray Blanton D-TN
- Robert Ashton Everett D-TN
- Olin Earl Teague D-TX
- William Robert Poage D-TX
- James Claude Wright Jr. D-TX
- Laurence Junior Burton R-UT
- Watkins Moorman Abbitt D-VA
- Richard Harding Poff R-VA
- Melvin Robert Laird R-WI
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To recede from disagreement with Senate…: House Vote, Dec 23, 1969,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/91-H-177/to-recede-from-disagreement-with-senate-amendment-33-to (accessed 2026-10-17).