House roll call 27 · 74th Congress · Mar 22, 1935
To recommit H.R. 3896 to the comm. On ways and means with instructions to substitute the so-called "tydings-andrews" bill (p. 4025-1) for the "patman plan" now
On Mar 22, 1935, the House voted 82–319 (HR 3896). Result: failed. By party: Democrats 45–255, Republicans 42–59, Others 0–10. It was a bipartisan vote: majorities of both parties voted no. 87 members voted against their own party.
During the 74th Congress (1935–1936), Franklin D. Roosevelt was president, and Democrats held majorities in both the House and Senate.
- Yes
- 82
- No
- 319
- Did not vote
- 16
- Date
- Mar 22, 1935
By party
- Democrats45 yes · 255 no · 14 didn’t vote
- Republicans42 yes · 59 no · 2 didn’t vote
- Others0 yes · 10 no
Who broke with their party
- Samuel Francis Hobbs D-AL voted yes
- William Bacon Oliver D-AL voted yes
- George Huddleston D-AL voted yes
- David Dickson Terry D-AR voted yes
- Frank Henry Buck D-CA voted yes
- Thomas Francis Ford D-CA voted yes
- Lawrence Lewis D-CO voted yes
- Herman Paul Kopplemann D-CT voted yes
- William Lincoln Higgins R-CT voted yes
- Schuyler Merritt R-CT voted yes
- John Joseph Smith D-CT voted yes
- Edward Eugene Cox D-GA voted yes
- Frederick Elliott Biermann D-IA voted yes
- Hubert Utterback D-IA voted yes
- Donald Claude Dobbins D-IL voted yes
- Samuel Barrett Pettengill D-IN voted yes
- James Indus Farley D-IN voted yes
- John William Boehne Jr. D-IN voted yes
- Emmet O'Neal D-KY voted yes
- Allen Towner Treadway R-MA voted yes
- Joseph Edward Casey D-MA voted yes
- Pehr Gustaf Holmes R-MA voted yes
- Edith Nourse Rogers R-MA voted yes
- Abram Piatt Andrew Jr. R-MA voted yes
- Richard Manning Russell D-MA voted yes
- George Holden Tinkham R-MA voted yes
- Richard Bowditch Wigglesworth R-MA voted yes
- Joseph William Martin Jr. R-MA voted yes
- Charles Laceille Gifford R-MA voted yes
- David John Lewis D-MD voted yes
- Clare Eugene Hoffman R-MI voted yes
- Carl Edgar Mapes R-MI voted yes
- Theodore Christianson R-MN voted yes
- Thomas Carey Hennings Jr. D-MO voted yes
- James Robert Claiborne D-MO voted yes
- John Joseph Cochran D-MO voted yes
- William Madison Whittington D-MS voted yes
- John Walter Lambeth D-NC voted yes
- Robert Lee Doughton D-NC voted yes
- Charles Francis Mclaughlin D-NE voted yes
- Charles William Tobey R-NH voted yes
- William Halstead Sutphin D-NJ voted yes
- Charles Aubrey Eaton R-NJ voted yes
- Donald Holman Mclean R-NJ voted yes
- Randolph Perkins R-NJ voted yes
- Fred Allan Hartley Jr. R-NJ voted yes
- Peter Angelo Cavicchia R-NJ voted yes
- Frederick Reimold Lehlbach R-NJ voted yes
- Robert Low Bacon R-NY voted yes
- John Joseph O'Connor D-NY voted yes
- Charles Dunsmore Millard R-NY voted yes
- Hamilton Fish R-NY voted yes
- Philip Arnold Goodwin R-NY voted yes
- William David Thomas R-NY voted yes
- Bertrand Hollis Snell R-NY voted yes
- Francis Dugan Culkin R-NY voted yes
- Frederick James Sisson D-NY voted yes
- Bert Lord R-NY voted yes
- Clarence Eugene Hancock R-NY voted yes
- John Taber R-NY voted yes
- William Sterling Cole R-NY voted yes
- James Patrick Duffy D-NY voted yes
- James Wolcott Wadsworth Jr. R-NY voted yes
- Walter Gresham Andrews R-NY voted yes
- Daniel Alden Reed R-NY voted yes
- Caroline Love Goodwin O'Day D-NY voted yes
- John Baker Hollister R-OH voted yes
- William Emil Hess R-OH voted yes
- Byron Berry Harlan D-OH voted yes
- Dow Watters Harter D-OH voted yes
- William Richard Thom D-OH voted yes
- Chester Castle Bolton R-OH voted yes
- William Henry Wilson R-PA voted yes
- George Potter Darrow R-PA voted yes
- Robert Fleming Rich R-PA voted yes
- Isaac Hoffer Doutrich R-PA voted yes
- Thomas Sanders Mcmillan D-SC voted yes
- Milton Horace West D-TX voted yes
- Schuyler Otis Bland D-VA voted yes
- Colgate Whitehead Darden Jr. D-VA voted yes
And 7 more.
How each representative voted: Yes
- Samuel Francis Hobbs D-AL
- William Bacon Oliver D-AL
- George Huddleston D-AL
- David Dickson Terry D-AR
- Frank Henry Buck D-CA
- Thomas Francis Ford D-CA
- Lawrence Lewis D-CO
- Herman Paul Kopplemann D-CT
- William Lincoln Higgins R-CT
- Schuyler Merritt R-CT
- John Joseph Smith D-CT
- Edward Eugene Cox D-GA
- Frederick Elliott Biermann D-IA
- Hubert Utterback D-IA
- Donald Claude Dobbins D-IL
- Samuel Barrett Pettengill D-IN
- James Indus Farley D-IN
- John William Boehne Jr. D-IN
- Emmet O'Neal D-KY
- Allen Towner Treadway R-MA
- Joseph Edward Casey D-MA
- Pehr Gustaf Holmes R-MA
- Edith Nourse Rogers R-MA
- Abram Piatt Andrew Jr. R-MA
- Richard Manning Russell D-MA
- George Holden Tinkham R-MA
- Richard Bowditch Wigglesworth R-MA
- Joseph William Martin Jr. R-MA
- Charles Laceille Gifford R-MA
- David John Lewis D-MD
- Clare Eugene Hoffman R-MI
- Carl Edgar Mapes R-MI
- Theodore Christianson R-MN
- Thomas Carey Hennings Jr. D-MO
- James Robert Claiborne D-MO
- John Joseph Cochran D-MO
- William Madison Whittington D-MS
- John Walter Lambeth D-NC
- Robert Lee Doughton D-NC
- Charles Francis Mclaughlin D-NE
- Charles William Tobey R-NH
- William Halstead Sutphin D-NJ
- Charles Aubrey Eaton R-NJ
- Donald Holman Mclean R-NJ
- Randolph Perkins R-NJ
- Fred Allan Hartley Jr. R-NJ
- Peter Angelo Cavicchia R-NJ
- Frederick Reimold Lehlbach R-NJ
- Robert Low Bacon R-NY
- John Joseph O'Connor D-NY
- Charles Dunsmore Millard R-NY
- Hamilton Fish R-NY
- Philip Arnold Goodwin R-NY
- William David Thomas R-NY
- Bertrand Hollis Snell R-NY
- Francis Dugan Culkin R-NY
- Frederick James Sisson D-NY
- Bert Lord R-NY
- Clarence Eugene Hancock R-NY
- John Taber R-NY
- William Sterling Cole R-NY
- James Patrick Duffy D-NY
- James Wolcott Wadsworth Jr. R-NY
- Walter Gresham Andrews R-NY
- Daniel Alden Reed R-NY
- Caroline Love Goodwin O'Day D-NY
- John Baker Hollister R-OH
- William Emil Hess R-OH
- Byron Berry Harlan D-OH
- Dow Watters Harter D-OH
- William Richard Thom D-OH
- Chester Castle Bolton R-OH
- William Henry Wilson R-PA
- George Potter Darrow R-PA
- Robert Fleming Rich R-PA
- Isaac Hoffer Doutrich R-PA
- Thomas Sanders Mcmillan D-SC
- Milton Horace West D-TX
- Schuyler Otis Bland D-VA
- Colgate Whitehead Darden Jr. D-VA
- Andrew Jackson Montague D-VA
- Patrick Henry Drewry D-VA
- Thomas Granville Burch D-VA
- Clifton Alexander Woodrum D-VA
- Absalom Willis Robertson D-VA
- Howard Worth Smith D-VA
- Charles Albert Plumley R-VT
How each representative voted: No
- Joseph Lister Hill D-AL
- Henry Bascom Steagall D-AL
- Joe Starnes D-AL
- Archibald Hill Carmichael D-AL
- William Joshua Driver D-AR
- John Elvis Miller D-AR
- Claude Albert Fuller D-AR
- William Ben Cravens D-AR
- John Little Mcclellan D-AR
- Tilman Bacon Parks D-AR
- Isabella Selmes Greenway D-AZ
- Clarence Frederick Lea D-CA
- Harry Lane Englebright R-CA
- Richard Joseph Welch R-CA
- Albert Edward Carter R-CA
- John Harvey Tolan D-CA
- John Joseph Mcgrath D-CA
- Bertrand Wesley Gearhart R-CA
- Henry Elbert Stubbs D-CA
- John Steven Mcgroarty D-CA
- John Henry Hoeppel D-CA
- Charles Kramer D-CA
- John Martin Costello D-CA
- John Francis Dockweiler D-CA
- Charles J. Colden D-CA
- Byron Nicholson Scott D-CA
- Samuel LaFort Collins R-CA
- George Burnham R-CA
- Fred Nelson Cummings D-CO
- John Andrew Martin D-CO
- Edward Thomas Taylor D-CO
- James Andrew Shanley D-CT
- William Michael Citron D-CT
- John George Stewart R-DE
- James Hardin Peterson D-FL
- Robert Alexis (Lex) Green D-FL
- Millard Fillmore Caldwell D-FL
- James Mark Wilcox D-FL
- William Joseph Sears D-FL
- Hugh Peterson D-GA
- Bryant Thomas Castellow D-GA
- Emmett Marshall Owen D-GA
- Robert C. Word Ramspeck D-GA
- Carl Vinson D-GA
- Malcolm Connor Tarver D-GA
- Braswell Drue Deen D-GA
- Benjamin Frank Whelchel D-GA
- Paul Brown D-GA
- Edward Clayton Eicher D-IA
- Bernhard Martin Jacobsen D-IA
- John Williams Gwynne R-IA
- Lloyd Thurston R-IA
- Otha Donner Wearin D-IA
- Fred Cramer Gilchrist R-IA
- Guy Mark Gillette D-IA
- Compton Ignatius White D-ID
- David Worth Clark D-ID
- Raymond Stephen Mckeough D-IL
- Edward Austin Kelly D-IL
- Harry Peter Beam D-IL
- Adolph Joachim Sabath D-IL
- Thomas Joseph O'Brien D-IL
- Leonard William Schuetz D-IL
- James Mcandrews D-IL
- Ralph Edwin Church R-IL
- Chauncey William Reed R-IL
- John Theodore Buckbee R-IL
- Leo Elwood Allen R-IL
- Chester Charles Thompson D-IL
- Jackson Leroy Adair D-IL
- Everett McKinley Dirksen R-IL
- Leslie Cornelius Arends R-IL
- Scott Wike Lucas D-IL
- Harry Howland Mason D-IL
- Edwin Martin Schaefer D-IL
- William Wright Arnold D-IL
- Claude VanCleve Parsons D-IL
- Kent Ellsworth Keller D-IL
- Martin Adlai Brennan D-IL
- William Theodore Schulte D-IN
- Charles Abraham Halleck R-IN
- Glenn Hasenfratz Griswold D-IN
- Virginia Ellis Jenckes D-IN
- Arthur Herbert Greenwood D-IN
- Eugene Burgess Crowe D-IN
- Finly Hutchinson Gray D-IN
- William Henry Larrabee D-IN
- Louis Leon Ludlow D-IN
- William Purnell Lambertson R-KS
- Ulysses Samuel Guyer R-KS
- Edward White Patterson D-KS
- William Randolph Carpenter D-KS
- John Mills Houston D-KS
- Frank Carlson R-KS
- Clifford Ragsdale Hope R-KS
- William Voris Gregory D-KY
- Glover H. Cary D-KY
- Cap Robert Carden D-KY
- Brent Spence D-KY
- Virgil Munday Chapman D-KY
- Andrew Jackson May D-KY
- Frederick Moore Vinson D-KY
- John Marshall Robsion R-KY
- Joachim Octave Fernández D-LA
- Paul Herbert Maloney D-LA
- Numa Francois Montet D-LA
- John Nicholas Sandlin D-LA
- Riley Joseph Wilson D-LA
- Jared Young Sanders Jr. D-LA
- Cleveland Dear D-LA
- William Joseph Granfield D-MA
- William Patrick Connery Jr. D-MA
- Arthur Daniel Healey D-MA
- John Patrick Higgins D-MA
- John William Mccormack D-MA
- Thomas Alan Goldsborough D-MD
- William Purington Cole Jr. D-MD
- Vincent Luke Palmisano D-MD
- Ambrose Jerome Kennedy D-MD
- Stephen Warfield Gambrill D-MD
- Simon Moulton Hamlin D-ME
- Edward Carleton Moran Jr. D-ME
- Ralph Owen Brewster R-ME
- George Gregory Sadowski D-MI
- Earl Cory Michener R-MI
- Henry Mahlon Kimball R-MI
- William Wallace Blackney R-MI
- Jesse Paine Wolcott R-MI
- Fred Lewis Crawford R-MI
- Albert Joseph Engel R-MI
- Roy Orchard Woodruff R-MI
- Prentiss Marsh Brown D-MI
- Frank Eugene Hook D-MI
- Louis Charles Rabaut D-MI
- John David Dingell D-MI
- John Lesinski D-MI
- George Anthony Dondero R-MI
- August Herman Andresen R-MN
- Elmer James Ryan D-MN
- Ernest Lundeen O-MN
- Melvin Joseph Maas R-MN
- Harold Knutson R-MN
- Paul John Kvale O-MN
- William Alvin Pittenger R-MN
- Richard Thompson Buckler O-MN
- Milton Andrew Romjue D-MO
- William Lester Nelson D-MO
- Richard Meloan Duncan D-MO
- Charles Jasper Bell D-MO
- Joseph Bernard Shannon D-MO
- Reuben Terrell Wood D-MO
- Dewey Jackson Short R-MO
- Clyde Williams D-MO
- Clarence Andrew Cannon D-MO
- Orville Zimmerman D-MO
- John Elliott Rankin D-MS
- Wall Doxey D-MS
- Aaron Lane Ford D-MS
- Aubert Culberson Dunn D-MS
- William Meyers Colmer D-MS
- Daniel Rayford Mcgehee D-MS
- Joseph Patrick Monaghan D-MT
- Roy Elmer Ayers D-MT
- Lindsay Carter Warren D-NC
- John Hosea Kerr D-NC
- Graham Arthur Barden D-NC
- Harold Dunbar Cooley D-NC
- Franklin Wills Hancock Jr. D-NC
- William Bradley Umstead D-NC
- Jerome Bayard Clark D-NC
- Zebulon Weaver D-NC
- Usher Lloyd Burdick R-ND
- William Lemke R-ND
- Henry Carl Luckey D-NE
- Karl Stefan R-NE
- Charles Gustav Binderup D-NE
- Harry Buffington Coffee D-NE
- William Nathaniel Rogers D-NH
- Charles Anderson Wolverton R-NJ
- Isaac Bacharach R-NJ
- David Lane Powers R-NJ
- George Nicholas Seger R-NJ
- Edward Aloysius Kenney D-NJ
- Mary Teresa Norton D-NJ
- Edward Joseph Hart D-NJ
- John Joseph Dempsey D-NM
- James Graves Scrugham D-NV
- William Frank Brunner D-NY
- Joseph Lawrence Pfeifer D-NY
- Thomas Henry Cullen D-NY
- Marcellus Hugh Evans D-NY
- Andrew Lawrence Somers D-NY
- John Joseph Delaney D-NY
- Richard Joseph Tonry D-NY
- Stephen Andrew Rudd D-NY
- Emanuel Celler D-NY
- James Aloysius O'Leary D-NY
- Samuel Dickstein D-NY
- Christopher Daniel Sullivan D-NY
- William Irving Sirovich D-NY
- John Joseph Boylan D-NY
- Martin John Kennedy D-NY
- Sol Bloom D-NY
- Vito Anthony Marcantonio R-NY
- Joseph Andrew Gavagan D-NY
- Charles Anthony Buckley D-NY
- James Martin Fitzpatrick D-NY
- Frank Crowther R-NY
- Alfred Florian Beiter D-NY
- James Michael Mead D-NY
- Matthew Joseph Merritt D-NY
- Frank Le Blond Kloeb D-OH
- Frank Charles Kniffin D-OH
- James Gould Polk D-OH
- Leroy Tate Marshall R-OH
- Thomas Brooks Fletcher D-OH
- Warren Joseph Duffey D-OH
- Thomas Albert Jenkins R-OH
- Mell Gilbert Underwood D-OH
- William Louis Fiesinger D-OH
- Robert Thompson Secrest D-OH
- William Albert Ashbrook D-OH
- Lawrence E. Imhoff D-OH
- John Gordon Cooper R-OH
- Martin Leonard Sweeney D-OH
- Robert Crosser D-OH
- Charles Vilas Truax D-OH
- Stephen Marvin Young D-OH
- Wesley Ernest Disney D-OK
- John Conover Nichols D-OK
- Wilburn Cartwright D-OK
- Percy Lee Gassaway D-OK
- Joshua Bryan Lee D-OK
- Jed Joseph Johnson D-OK
- Samuel Chapman Massingale D-OK
- Phillip Colgan Ferguson D-OK
- Will Rogers D-OK
- James Wheaton Mott R-OR
- Walter Marcus Pierce D-OR
- William Alexander Ekwall R-OR
- Harry Clay Ransley R-PA
- Clare Gerald Fenerty R-PA
- Frank Joseph Gerard Dorsey D-PA
- Michael Joseph Stack D-PA
- James Wolfenden R-PA
- Oliver Walter Frey D-PA
- John Roland Kinzer R-PA
- Patrick Joseph Boland D-PA
- Charles Murray Turpin R-PA
- James Hilary Gildea D-PA
- Charles Elmer Dietrich D-PA
- John William Ditter R-PA
- Benjamin Kurtz Focht R-PA
- Denis Joseph Driscoll D-PA
- Francis Eugene Walter D-PA
- Harry Luther Haines D-PA
- Don Gingery D-PA
- John Buell Snyder D-PA
- Charles Isiah Faddis D-PA
- Charles Richard Eckert D-PA
- Joseph Anthony Gray D-PA
- William Markle Berlin D-PA
- Charles Noel Crosby D-PA
- Joshua Twing Brooks D-PA
- James Leland Quinn D-PA
- Theodore Leo Moritz D-PA
- Henry Ellenbogen D-PA
- Matthew Anthony Dunn D-PA
- John Matthew O'Connell D-RI
- Hampton Pitts Fulmer D-SC
- John Clarence Taylor D-SC
- John Jackson Mcswain D-SC
- James Prioleau Richards D-SC
- Allard Henry Gasque D-SC
- Fred Herman Hildebrandt D-SD
- Theodore B. Werner D-SD
- Brazilla Carroll Reece R-TN
- James Willis Taylor R-TN
- John Ridley Mitchell D-TN
- Clarence Wyly Turner D-TN
- Herron Carney Pearson D-TN
- Jere Cooper D-TN
- John William Wright Patman D-TX
- Martin Dies Jr. D-TX
- Morgan Gurley Sanders D-TX
- Hatton William Sumners D-TX
- Luther Alexander Johnson D-TX
- Nat Patton D-TX
- Joe Henry Eagle D-TX
- Joseph Jefferson Mansfield D-TX
- James Paul Buchanan D-TX
- Oliver Harlan Cross D-TX
- William Doddridge Mcfarlane D-TX
- Richard Mifflin Kleberg Sr. D-TX
- Robert Ewing Thomason D-TX
- Thomas Lindsay Blanton D-TX
- John Marvin Jones D-TX
- George Herman Mahon D-TX
- Fontaine Maury Maverick D-TX
- Charles Lacy South D-TX
- Orrice Abram Murdock Jr. (Abe) D-UT
- James William Robinson D-UT
- John William Flannagan Jr. D-VA
- Marion Anthony Zioncheck D-WA
- Monrad Charles Wallgren D-WA
- Martin Fernard Smith D-WA
- Knute Hill D-WA
- Samuel Billingsley Hill D-WA
- Wesley Lloyd D-WA
- Thomas Ryum Amlie O-WI
- Harry Sauthoff O-WI
- Gardner Robert Withrow O-WI
- Raymond Joseph Cannon D-WI
- Thomas David Patrick O'Malley D-WI
- Gerald John Boileau O-WI
- George John Schneider O-WI
- Merlin Hull O-WI
- Bernard John Gehrmann O-WI
- Robert Lincoln Ramsay D-WV
- Jennings Randolph D-WV
- Andrew Edmiston D-WV
- John Kee D-WV
- Joseph Luther Smith D-WV
- Paul Ranous Greever D-WY
Voted present
- William Brockman Bankhead D-AL
- Florence Prag Kahn R-CA
- James Andrew Meeks D-IL
- Michael Lambert Igoe D-IL
- René Louis De Rouen D-LA
- Clarence John Mcleod R-MI
- Alfred Lee Bulwinkle D-NC
- Theodore Albert Peyser D-NY
- Arthur Philip Lamneck D-OH
- William Emanuel Richardson D-PA
- Samuel Davis Mcreynolds D-TN
- Walter (Clift) Chandler D-TN
- Samuel Taliaferro Rayburn D-TX
- George William Johnson D-WV
Did not vote
- Frank William Boykin D-AL
- John Mcduffie D-AL
- Arthur Wergs Mitchell D-IL
- Leo Paul Kocialkowski D-IL
- Edward Wester Creal D-KY
- Verner Wright Main R-MI
- William Bernard Barry D-NY
- Anthony Jerome Griffin D-NY
- Edward Walter Curley D-NY
- Parker Corning D-NY
- John Burrwood Daly D-PA
- Charles Francis Risk R-RI
- Francis Bernard Condon D-RI
- Joseph Wellington Byrns D-TN
- Fritz Garland Lanham D-TX
- Michael Kieran Reilly D-WI
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To recommit H.R. 3896 to the comm. On ways…: House Vote, Mar 22, 1935,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/74-H-27/to-recommit-h-r-3896-to-the-comm-on (accessed 2026-10-15).