House roll call 36 · 68th Congress · Mar 11, 1924
To amend, in the nature of a substitute, H. RES. 216, by requesting the attorney general for a responsive answer to the request sent by the house in H. RES. 211
On Mar 11, 1924, the House voted 152–184 (HRE 216). Result: failed. By party: Democrats 140–37, Republicans 16–152, Others 1–0. It was a split vote: the parties took opposite sides, with some members crossing over. 53 members voted against their own party.
During the 68th Congress (1923–1924), Calvin Coolidge was president, and Republicans held majorities in both the House and Senate.
- Yes
- 152
- No
- 184
- Did not vote
- 90
- Date
- Mar 11, 1924
By party
- Democrats140 yes · 37 no · 32 didn’t vote
- Republicans16 yes · 152 no · 57 didn’t vote
- Others1 yes · 0 no · 1 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- John Newton Tillman D-AR voted no
- Heartsill Ragon D-AR voted no
- Clarence Frederick Lea D-CA voted no
- John Edward Raker D-CA voted no
- Walter Franklin Lineberger R-CA voted yes
- Patrick Brett O'Sullivan D-CT voted no
- William Henry Boyce D-DE voted no
- John Harris Smithwick D-FL voted no
- William Carter Wright D-GA voted no
- Charles Hillyer Brand D-GA voted no
- James Richard Buckley D-IL voted no
- Edward John King R-IL voted yes
- William Edward Wilson D-IN voted no
- William Henry Sproul R-KS voted yes
- Alben William Barkley D-KY voted no
- Arthur Blythe Rouse D-KY voted no
- Ralph Waldo Emerson Gilbert D-KY voted no
- Frederick Moore Vinson D-KY voted no
- William Francis James R-MI voted yes
- Oscar Edward Keller R-MN voted yes
- Milton Andrew Romjue D-MO voted no
- Samuel Collier Major D-MO voted no
- Thomas Lewis Rubey D-MO voted no
- Bill Green Lowrey D-MS voted no
- William Yerger Humphreys D-MS voted no
- William Cicero Hammer D-NC voted no
- Robert Lee Doughton D-NC voted no
- Zebulon Weaver D-NC voted no
- James Herbert Sinclair R-ND voted yes
- John Henry Morehead D-NE voted no
- Ashton Cokayne Shallenberger D-NE voted no
- Charles Lenmore Richards D-NV voted no
- Anthony Jerome Griffin D-NY voted no
- Parker Corning D-NY voted no
- John Mcsweeney D-OH voted no
- Thomas Deitz Mckeown D-OK voted no
- Melville Clyde Kelly R-PA voted yes
- Joseph Wellington Byrns D-TN voted no
- Samuel Taliaferro Rayburn D-TX voted no
- Hatton William Sumners D-TX voted no
- Fritz Garland Lanham D-TX voted no
- Guinn Williams D-TX voted no
- Andrew Jackson Montague D-VA voted no
- Thomas Walter Harrison D-VA voted no
- John William Summers R-WA voted yes
- Henry Allen Cooper R-WI voted yes
- John Charles Schafer R-WI voted yes
- Florian Lampert R-WI voted yes
- Joseph David Beck R-WI voted yes
- Edward Everts Browne R-WI voted yes
- George John Schneider R-WI voted yes
- James Archibald Frear R-WI voted yes
- Hubert Haskell Peavey R-WI voted yes
How each representative voted: Yes
- Joseph Lister Hill D-AL
- Henry Bascom Steagall D-AL
- Lamar Jeffers D-AL
- William Bismarck Bowling D-AL
- William Bacon Oliver D-AL
- Miles Clayton Allgood D-AL
- Edward Berton Almon D-AL
- George Huddleston D-AL
- William Brockman Bankhead D-AL
- William Joshua Driver D-AR
- William Allan Oldfield D-AR
- Otis Theodore Wingo D-AR
- James Byron Reed D-AR
- Tilman Bacon Parks D-AR
- Carl Trumbull Hayden D-AZ
- Walter Franklin Lineberger R-CA
- Herbert Jackson Drane D-FL
- Frank Clark D-FL
- William Joseph Sears D-FL
- Robert Lee Moore D-GA
- Frank Park D-GA
- Charles Robert Crisp D-GA
- William David Upshaw D-GA
- Thomas Montgomery Bell D-GA
- Carl Vinson D-GA
- William Chester Lankford D-GA
- William Washington Larsen D-GA
- Stanley Henry Kunz D-IL
- Edward John King R-IL
- Henry Thomas Rainey D-IL
- James Earl Major D-IL
- William Wright Arnold D-IL
- Arthur Herbert Greenwood D-IN
- Frank Gardner D-IN
- Harry Clifford Canfield D-IN
- Samuel Ellis Cook D-IN
- William Henry Sproul R-KS
- William Augustus Ayres D-KS
- David Hayes Kincheloe D-KY
- Robert Young Thomas Jr. D-KY
- Joseph Watkins Morris D-KY
- James O'Connor D-LA
- Whitmell Pugh Martin D-LA
- John Nicholas Sandlin D-LA
- Riley Joseph Wilson D-LA
- George Kent Favrot D-LA
- Ladislas Lazaro D-LA
- James Benjamin Aswell D-LA
- William Patrick Connery Jr. D-MA
- Peter Francis Tague D-MA
- Millard Evelyn Tydings D-MD
- John Charles Linthicum D-MD
- Robert Henry Clancy D-MI
- William Francis James R-MI
- Oscar Edward Keller R-MN
- Knud Wefald O-MN
- Ralph Fulton Lozier D-MO
- Jacob Le Roy Milligan D-MO
- Clement Cabell Dickinson D-MO
- Clarence Andrew Cannon D-MO
- Joseph Scott Wolff D-MO
- James Franklin Fulbright D-MO
- John Elliott Rankin D-MS
- Thomas Jefferson Busby D-MS
- Thomas Webber Wilson D-MS
- Percy Edwards Quin D-MS
- James William Collier D-MS
- John Morgan Evans D-MT
- Hallett Sydney Ward D-NC
- Edward William Pou D-NC
- Charles Manly Stedman D-NC
- Homer Le Grand Lyon D-NC
- Alfred Lee Bulwinkle D-NC
- James Herbert Sinclair R-ND
- Edgar Howard D-NE
- Elmer Hendrickson Geran D-NJ
- Frank Joseph Mcnulty D-NJ
- Daniel Francis Minahan D-NJ
- John Joseph Eagan D-NJ
- John Joseph Kindred D-NY
- George Washington Lindsay D-NY
- Thomas Henry Cullen D-NY
- Loring Milton Black Jr. D-NY
- Charles Irwin Stengle D-NY
- John Francis Quayle D-NY
- William Edward Cleary D-NY
- David Joseph O'Connell D-NY
- Emanuel Celler D-NY
- Anning Smith Prall D-NY
- Samuel Dickstein D-NY
- Christopher Daniel Sullivan D-NY
- John Joseph Boylan D-NY
- John Joseph O'Connor D-NY
- John Francis Carew D-NY
- Sol Bloom D-NY
- Royal Hurlburt Weller D-NY
- Frank Oliver D-NY
- Meyer Jacobstein D-NY
- James Michael Mead D-NY
- Isaac R. Sherwood D-OH
- Mell Gilbert Underwood D-OH
- Charles Anthony Mooney D-OH
- Robert Crosser D-OH
- Everette Burgess Howard D-OK
- William Wirt Hastings D-OK
- Charles David Carter D-OK
- Fletcher B. Swank D-OK
- John William Elmer Thomas D-OK
- Elton Watkins D-OR
- William Martin Croll D-PA
- Herbert Wesley Cummings D-PA
- Samuel Feiser Glatfelter D-PA
- Everett Kent D-PA
- Melville Clyde Kelly R-PA
- Jeremiah Edward O'Connell D-RI
- James Francis Byrnes D-SC
- Frederick Haskell Dominick D-SC
- John Jackson Mcswain D-SC
- William Francis Stevenson D-SC
- Allard Henry Gasque D-SC
- Samuel Davis Mcreynolds D-TN
- Ewin Lamar Davis D-TN
- William Charles Salmon D-TN
- Gordon Weaver Browning D-TN
- Finis James Garrett D-TN
- Hubert Frederick Fisher D-TN
- John Calvin Box D-TX
- Morgan Gurley Sanders D-TX
- Luther Alexander Johnson D-TX
- Clay Stone Briggs D-TX
- Daniel Edward Garrett D-TX
- Joseph Jefferson Mansfield D-TX
- James Paul Buchanan D-TX
- Thomas Terry (Tom) Connally D-TX
- John Nance Garner D-TX
- Claude Benton Hudspeth D-TX
- John Marvin Jones D-TX
- Schuyler Otis Bland D-VA
- Joseph Thomas Deal D-VA
- Patrick Henry Drewry D-VA
- James Murray Hooker D-VA
- Clifton Alexander Woodrum D-VA
- Robert Walton Moore D-VA
- Henry St. George Tucker D-VA
- John William Summers R-WA
- Samuel Billingsley Hill D-WA
- Henry Allen Cooper R-WI
- John Charles Schafer R-WI
- Florian Lampert R-WI
- Joseph David Beck R-WI
- Edward Everts Browne R-WI
- George John Schneider R-WI
- James Archibald Frear R-WI
- Hubert Haskell Peavey R-WI
- Robert Edward Lee Allen D-WV
- George William Johnson D-WV
- James Alfred Taylor D-WV
How each representative voted: No
- John Newton Tillman D-AR
- Heartsill Ragon D-AR
- Clarence Frederick Lea D-CA
- John Edward Raker D-CA
- Charles Forrest Curry R-CA
- James Henry Maclafferty R-CA
- Henry Ellsworth Barbour R-CA
- Arthur Monroe Free R-CA
- John Donnan Fredericks R-CA
- Philip David Swing R-CA
- William Newell Vaile R-CO
- Charles Bateman Timberlake R-CO
- Guy Urban Hardy R-CO
- Edward Hart Fenn R-CT
- Richard Patrick Freeman R-CT
- Schuyler Merritt R-CT
- Patrick Brett O'Sullivan D-CT
- William Henry Boyce D-DE
- John Harris Smithwick D-FL
- William Carter Wright D-GA
- Charles Hillyer Brand D-GA
- William Frederick Kopp R-IA
- Harry Edward Hull R-IA
- Thomas John Bright Robinson R-IA
- Gilbert Nelson Haugen R-IA
- Cyrenus Cole R-IA
- Christian William Ramseyer R-IA
- Cassius Clay Dowell R-IA
- Hiram Kinsman Evans R-IA
- William Raymond Green R-IA
- Lester Jesse Dickinson R-IA
- William Dayton Boies R-IA
- Burton Lee French R-ID
- Addison Taylor Smith R-ID
- Martin Barnaby Madden R-IL
- Morton Denison Hull R-IL
- Elliott Wilford Sproul R-IL
- James Richard Buckley D-IL
- Carl Richard Chindblom R-IL
- John Charles Mckenzie R-IL
- William Johnson Graham R-IL
- William Edgar Hull R-IL
- Richard Yates R-IL
- William Edward Wilson D-IN
- Richard Nash Elliott R-IN
- Merrill Moores R-IN
- Albert Henry Vestal R-IN
- Fred Sampson Purnell R-IN
- William Robert Wood R-IN
- Louis William Fairfield R-IN
- Andrew James Hickey R-IN
- Edward Campbell Little R-KS
- Homer Hoch R-KS
- James George Strong R-KS
- Hays Baxter White R-KS
- Alben William Barkley D-KY
- Maurice Hudson Thatcher R-KY
- Arthur Blythe Rouse D-KY
- Ralph Waldo Emerson Gilbert D-KY
- Frederick Moore Vinson D-KY
- John Marshall Robsion R-KY
- Allen Towner Treadway R-MA
- Calvin DeWitt Paige R-MA
- John Jacob Rogers R-MA
- Abram Piatt Andrew Jr. R-MA
- Frederick William Dallinger R-MA
- Charles Lee Underhill R-MA
- George Holden Tinkham R-MA
- William Stedman Greene R-MA
- Charles Laceille Gifford R-MA
- John Boynton Philip Clayton Hill R-MD
- Carroll Lynwood Beedy R-ME
- Wallace Humphrey White Jr. R-ME
- John Edward Nelson R-ME
- Ira Greenlief Hersey R-ME
- Earl Cory Michener R-MI
- Arthur Bruce Williams R-MI
- John Clark Ketcham R-MI
- Carl Edgar Mapes R-MI
- Grant Martin Hudson R-MI
- Louis Convers Cramton R-MI
- Bird J. Vincent R-MI
- James Campbell Mclaughlin R-MI
- Roy Orchard Woodruff R-MI
- Frank Douglas Scott R-MI
- Frank Clague R-MN
- Charles Russell Davis R-MN
- Walter Hughes Newton R-MN
- Oscar John Larson R-MN
- Thomas David Schall R-MN
- Milton Andrew Romjue D-MO
- Charles Lee Faust R-MO
- Samuel Collier Major D-MO
- Sidney Crain Roach R-MO
- Cleveland Alexander Newton R-MO
- Leonidas Carstarphen Dyer R-MO
- Joe Jonathan Manlove R-MO
- Thomas Lewis Rubey D-MO
- Bill Green Lowrey D-MS
- William Yerger Humphreys D-MS
- Scott Leavitt R-MT
- William Cicero Hammer D-NC
- Robert Lee Doughton D-NC
- Zebulon Weaver D-NC
- Olger Burton Burtness R-ND
- George Morley Young R-ND
- John Henry Morehead D-NE
- Willis Gratz Sears R-NE
- Ashton Cokayne Shallenberger D-NE
- Robert Glenmore Simmons R-NE
- Isaac Bacharach R-NJ
- Ernest Robinson Ackerman R-NJ
- Randolph Perkins R-NJ
- Charles Lenmore Richards D-NV
- Robert Low Bacon R-NY
- Fiorello Henry La Guardia R-NY
- Anthony Jerome Griffin D-NY
- Benjamin Lewis Fairchild R-NY
- Hamilton Fish R-NY
- Charles Bonnell Ward R-NY
- Parker Corning D-NY
- James Southworth Parker R-NY
- Frank Crowther R-NY
- Bertrand Hollis Snell R-NY
- Homer Peter Snyder R-NY
- John Davenport Clarke R-NY
- Walter Warren Magee R-NY
- Gale Hamilton Stalker R-NY
- Clarence Macgregor R-NY
- Daniel Alden Reed R-NY
- Nicholas Longworth R-OH
- Ambrose Everett Burnside Stephens R-OH
- Roy Gerald Fitzgerald R-OH
- Charles James Thompson R-OH
- Israel Moore Foster R-OH
- John Charles Speaks R-OH
- James Thomas Begg R-OH
- Charles Ellis Moore R-OH
- John Mcsweeney D-OH
- William Mitchell Morgan R-OH
- Benjamin Franklin Murphy R-OH
- John Gordon Cooper R-OH
- Theodore Elijah Burton R-OH
- Thomas Deitz Mckeown D-OK
- Willis Chatman Hawley R-OR
- Nicholas John Sinnott R-OR
- George Scott Graham R-PA
- Harry Clay Ransley R-PA
- George Washington Edmonds R-PA
- James Joseph Connolly R-PA
- George Austin Welsh R-PA
- George Potter Darrow R-PA
- Thomas Stalker Butler R-PA
- Henry Winfield Watson R-PA
- William Walton Griest R-PA
- Laurence Hawley Watres R-PA
- Edward McMath Beers R-PA
- Jacob Banks Kurtz R-PA
- William Irvin Swoope R-PA
- Henry Wilson Temple R-PA
- Thomas Wharton Phillips Jr. R-PA
- Nathan Leroy Strong R-PA
- Harris Jacob Bixler R-PA
- Stephen Geyer Porter R-PA
- James McDevitt Magee R-PA
- Guy Edgar Campbell R-PA
- Clark Burdick R-RI
- Richard Steere Aldrich R-RI
- Charles Andrew Christopherson R-SD
- William Williamson R-SD
- Brazilla Carroll Reece R-TN
- James Willis Taylor R-TN
- Joseph Wellington Byrns D-TN
- Samuel Taliaferro Rayburn D-TX
- Hatton William Sumners D-TX
- Fritz Garland Lanham D-TX
- Guinn Williams D-TX
- Harry McLeary Wurzbach R-TX
- Don Byron Colton R-UT
- Elmer O. Leatherwood R-UT
- Andrew Jackson Montague D-VA
- Thomas Walter Harrison D-VA
- Frederick Gleed Fleetwood R-VT
- Ernest Willard Gibson R-VT
- John Franklin Miller R-WA
- Lindley Hoag Hadley R-WA
- Albert Johnson R-WA
- John Mandt Nelson R-WI
- Charles Edwin Winter R-WY
Voted present
Did not vote
- John Mcduffie D-AL
- Julius Kahn R-CA
- Mae Ella Nolan R-CA
- Edward Thomas Taylor D-CO
- John Quillin Tilson R-CT
- James Walter Wise D-GA
- Gordon Lee D-GA
- John William Rainey D-IL
- Thomas Aloysius Doyle D-IL
- Adolph Joachim Sabath D-IL
- Magne Alfred Michaelson R-IL
- Frederick Albert Britten R-IL
- Frank R. Reid R-IL
- Charles Eugene Fuller R-IL
- Frank Hamilton Funk R-IL
- William Perry Holaday R-IL
- Allen Francis Moore R-IL
- Edward Edwin Miller R-IL
- Thomas Sutler Williams R-IL
- Edward Everett Denison R-IL
- Henry Riggs Rathbone R-IL
- Everett Sanders R-IN
- Daniel Read Anthony Jr. R-KS
- Ulysses Samuel Guyer R-KS
- Jasper Napoleon Tincher R-KS
- Ben Johnson D-KY
- William Jason Fields D-KY
- John Wesley Langley R-KY
- Henry Garland Dupré D-LA
- James Zacharie Spearing D-LA
- Frederick Huntington Gillett R-MA
- Samuel Ellsworth Winslow R-MA
- James Ambrose Gallivan D-MA
- Robert Luce R-MA
- Louis Adams Frothingham R-MA
- Robert Milton Leach R-MA
- Thomas Alan Goldsborough D-MD
- Stephen Warfield Gambrill D-MD
- Sydney Emanuel Mudd R-MD
- Frederick Nicholas Zihlman R-MD
- Clarence John Mcleod R-MI
- Sydney Anderson R-MN
- Harold Knutson R-MN
- Ole Juulson Kvale O-MN
- Henry Lee Jost D-MO
- Harry Bartow Hawes D-MO
- John Hosea Kerr D-NC
- Charles Laban Abernethy D-NC
- Thomas Hall R-ND
- Melvin Orlando Mclaughlin R-NE
- Francis Ford Patterson Jr. R-NJ
- Charles Browne D-NJ
- Frederick Reimold Lehlbach R-NJ
- Charles Francis Xavier O'Brien D-NJ
- John Morrow D-NM
- Nathan David Perlman R-NY
- Ogden Livingston Mills R-NY
- Jonathan Mayhew Wainwright R-NY
- Thaddeus C. Sweet R-NY
- John Taber R-NY
- Archie Dovell Sanders R-NY
- Stephen Wallace Dempsey R-NY
- John Levi Cable R-OH
- Charles Cyrus Kearns R-OH
- Charles Brand R-OH
- Raymond Clinton Cole R-OH
- Martin Luther Davey D-OH
- James Vernon Mcclintic D-OK
- Milton Cline Garber R-OK
- William Scott Vare R-PA
- John Joseph Casey D-PA
- George Franklin Brumm R-PA
- Louis Thomas Mcfadden R-PA
- Frank Crawford Sites D-PA
- George M. Wertz R-PA
- Samuel Austin Kendall R-PA
- Milton William Shreve R-PA
- Adam Martin Wyant R-PA
- John Mary Morin R-PA
- William Turner Logan D-SC
- Hampton Pitts Fulmer D-SC
- Royal Cleaves Johnson R-SD
- Cordell Hull D-TN
- Eugene Black D-TX
- Thomas Lindsay Blanton D-TX
- George Campbell Peery D-VA
- Edward Voigt R-WI
- Benjamin Louis Rosenbloom R-WV
- Stuart Felix Reed R-WV
- Thomas Jefferson Lilly D-WV
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To amend, in the nature of a substitute, H…: House Vote, Mar 11, 1924,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/68-H-36/to-amend-in-the-nature-of-a-substitute-h (accessed 2026-10-17).