House roll call 15 · 57th Congress · Feb 12, 1902
To recommit H.R. 9206 with instructions to report the following bill as a substitute; "a bill to amend sections 3 and 6 of an act entitled "an act defining butt
On Feb 12, 1902, the House voted 116–163 (HR 9206). Result: failed. By party: Republicans 28–122, Democrats 87–38, Others 1–3. It was a split vote: the parties took opposite sides, with some members crossing over. 66 members voted against their own party.
During the 57th Congress (1901–1902), Theodore Roosevelt was president, and Republicans held majorities in both the House and Senate.
- Yes
- 116
- No
- 163
- Did not vote
- 92
- Date
- Feb 12, 1902
By party
- Democrats87 yes · 38 no · 35 didn’t vote
- Republicans28 yes · 122 no · 55 didn’t vote
- Others1 yes · 3 no · 2 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- Julius Kahn R-CA voted yes
- Eugene Francis Loud R-CA voted yes
- Thomas Hedge R-IA voted yes
- James Robert Mann R-IL voted yes
- Henry Sherman Boutell R-IL voted yes
- J. Ross Mickey D-IL voted no
- Thomas Jefferson Selby D-IL voted no
- Ben Franklin Caldwell D-IL voted no
- Thomas Marion Jett D-IL voted no
- James Robert Williams D-IL voted no
- Frederick John Kern D-IL voted no
- Robert Walter Miers D-IN voted no
- William Taylor Zenor D-IN voted no
- Francis Marion Griffith D-IN voted no
- Jesse Overstreet R-IN voted yes
- Edgar Dean Crumpacker R-IN voted yes
- George Washington Steele R-IN voted yes
- James McClellan Robinson D-IN voted no
- Justin De Witt Bowersock R-KS voted yes
- Alfred Metcalf Jackson D-KS voted no
- Chester Isaiah Long R-KS voted yes
- Daniel Linn Gooch D-KY voted no
- George Gilmore Gilbert D-KY voted no
- John Randolph Thayer D-MA voted no
- Samuel Walker Mccall R-MA voted yes
- Joseph Aloysius Conry D-MA voted no
- William Croad Lovering R-MA voted yes
- Frank Charles Wachter R-MD voted yes
- Charles Reginald Schirm R-MD voted yes
- James Tilghman Lloyd D-MO voted no
- John Dougherty D-MO voted no
- David Albaugh De Armond D-MO voted no
- James Cooney D-MO voted no
- James Beauchamp (Champ) Clark D-MO voted no
- Charles Frederick Joy R-MO voted yes
- Edward Robb D-MO voted no
- Willard Duncan Vandiver D-MO voted no
- Edward William Pou D-NC voted no
- John Seaton Robinson D-NE voted no
- Ashton Cokayne Shallenberger D-NE voted no
- Henry Clay Loudenslager R-NJ voted yes
- Joshua S. Salmon D-NJ voted no
- Francis Griffith Newlands D-NV voted no
- Harry Alfred Hanbury R-NY voted yes
- George Henry Lindsay D-NY voted no
- Montague Lessler R-NY voted yes
- William Harris Douglas R-NY voted yes
- James Wolcott Wadsworth R-NY voted yes
- Jacob Henry Bromwell R-OH voted yes
- Robert Bryarly Gordon D-OH voted no
- John Stout Snook D-OH voted no
- John Wilson Cassingham D-OH voted no
- Theodore Elijah Burton R-OH voted yes
- Robert Adams Jr. R-PA voted yes
- Henry Burk R-PA voted yes
- Howard Mutchler D-PA voted no
- Henry Dickinson Green D-PA voted no
- William Connell R-PA voted yes
- John Dalzell R-PA voted yes
- James Knox Polk Hall D-PA voted no
- William Atkinson Jones D-VA voted no
- John Lamb D-VA voted no
- Peter Johnston Otey D-VA voted no
- John Franklin Rixey D-VA voted no
- James Anthony Hughes R-WV voted yes
- Frank Wheeler Mondell R-WY voted yes
How each representative voted: Yes
- Ariosto Appling Wiley D-AL
- Henry De Lamar Clayton D-AL
- Sydney Johnston Bowie D-AL
- Charles Winston Thompson D-AL
- John Lawson Burnett D-AL
- William Richardson D-AL
- Oscar Wilder Underwood D-AL
- Philip Doddridge Mcculloch Jr. D-AR
- John Sebastian Little D-AR
- Thomas Chipman Mcrae D-AR
- Charles Chester Reid D-AR
- Hugh Anderson Dinsmore D-AR
- Stephen Brundidge Jr. D-AR
- Julius Kahn R-CA
- Eugene Francis Loud R-CA
- Stephen Milancthon Sparkman D-FL
- Robert Wyche Davis D-FL
- Rufus Ezekiel Lester D-GA
- Elijah Banks Lewis D-GA
- William Charles Adamson D-GA
- Leonidas Felix Livingston D-GA
- John W. Maddox D-GA
- William Marcellus Howard D-GA
- Farish Carter Tate D-GA
- William Henry Fleming D-GA
- William Gordon Brantley D-GA
- Thomas Hedge R-IA
- James Robert Mann R-IL
- John Joseph Feely D-IL
- George Peter Foster D-IL
- James Mcandrews D-IL
- William Frank Mahoney D-IL
- Henry Sherman Boutell R-IL
- Jesse Overstreet R-IN
- Edgar Dean Crumpacker R-IN
- George Washington Steele R-IN
- Justin De Witt Bowersock R-KS
- Chester Isaiah Long R-KS
- Charles Kennedy Wheeler D-KY
- Henry Dixon Allen D-KY
- John Stockdale Rhea D-KY
- David Highbaugh Smith D-KY
- James Nicholas Kehoe D-KY
- James Bamford White D-KY
- Robert Charles Davey D-LA
- Joseph Eugene Ransdell D-LA
- Samuel Matthews Robertson D-LA
- Samuel Walker Mccall R-MA
- Henry Francis Naphen D-MA
- William Croad Lovering R-MA
- Frank Charles Wachter R-MD
- Charles Reginald Schirm R-MD
- William Waller Rucker D-MO
- William Strother Cowherd D-MO
- Charles Frederick Joy R-MO
- James Joseph Butler D-MO
- Ezekiel Samuel Candler Jr. D-MS
- Patrick Henry D-MS
- Andrew Fuller Fox D-MS
- John Sharp Williams D-MS
- Frank Alexander Mclain D-MS
- Charles Edward Hooker D-MS
- Caldwell Edwards O-MT
- John Humphrey Small D-NC
- Claude Kitchin D-NC
- William Walton Kitchin D-NC
- Henry Clay Loudenslager R-NJ
- Allan Langdon Mcdermott D-NJ
- Harry Alfred Hanbury R-NY
- Frank Eugene Wilson D-NY
- Montague Lessler R-NY
- Thomas James Creamer D-NY
- Henry Mayer Goldfogle D-NY
- Amos Jay Cummings D-NY
- George Brinton Mcclellan D-NY
- William Harris Douglas R-NY
- Jacob Ruppert Jr. D-NY
- James Wolcott Wadsworth R-NY
- William Henry Ryan D-NY
- Jacob Henry Bromwell R-OH
- Theodore Elijah Burton R-OH
- Robert Adams Jr. R-PA
- Henry Burk R-PA
- William Connell R-PA
- John Dalzell R-PA
- William Elliott D-SC
- William Jasper Talbert D-SC
- Asbury Churchwell Latimer D-SC
- Joseph Travis Johnson D-SC
- Robert Bethea Scarborough D-SC
- Asbury Francis Lever D-SC
- John Austin Moon D-TN
- Charles Edward Snodgrass D-TN
- James Daniel Richardson D-TN
- John Wesley Gaines D-TN
- Lemuel Phillips Padgett D-TN
- Thetus Willrette Sims D-TN
- Rice Alexander Pierce D-TN
- Malcolm Rice Patterson D-TN
- Thomas Henry Ball D-TX
- Samuel Bronson Cooper D-TX
- Reese Calhoun De Graffenreid D-TX
- John Levi Sheppard D-TX
- Choice Boswell Randell D-TX
- Dudley Goodall Wooten D-TX
- Robert Lee Henry D-TX
- Samuel Willis Tucker Lanham D-TX
- Albert Sidney Burleson D-TX
- George Farmer Burgess D-TX
- Rudolph Kleberg D-TX
- James Luther Slayden D-TX
- John Hall Stephens D-TX
- Harry Lee Maynard D-VA
- Francis Rives Lassiter D-VA
- James Anthony Hughes R-WV
- Frank Wheeler Mondell R-WY
How each representative voted: No
- Frank Leslie Coombs R-CA
- Samuel Davis Woods R-CA
- Victor Howard Metcalf R-CA
- James Mclachlan R-CA
- James Carson Needham R-CA
- John Franklin Shafroth O-CO
- John Calhoun Bell O-CO
- Edward Stevens Henry R-CT
- Nehemiah Day Sperry R-CT
- Charles Addison Russell R-CT
- Ebenezer J. Hill R-CT
- Lewis Heisler Ball R-DE
- John Nicholas William Rumple R-IA
- Gilbert Nelson Haugen R-IA
- John Fletcher Lacey R-IA
- John Albert Tiffin Hull R-IA
- William Peters Hepburn R-IA
- James Perry Conner R-IA
- Lot Thomas R-IA
- George Washington Prince R-IL
- Joseph Gurney Cannon R-IL
- Vespasian Warner R-IL
- J. Ross Mickey D-IL
- Thomas Jefferson Selby D-IL
- Ben Franklin Caldwell D-IL
- Thomas Marion Jett D-IL
- James Robert Williams D-IL
- Frederick John Kern D-IL
- George Washington Smith R-IL
- Robert Walter Miers D-IN
- William Taylor Zenor D-IN
- Francis Marion Griffith D-IN
- James Eli Watson R-IN
- James McClellan Robinson D-IN
- Charles Curtis R-KS
- Alfred Metcalf Jackson D-KS
- James Monroe Miller R-KS
- William Alexander Calderhead R-KS
- Daniel Linn Gooch D-KY
- George Gilmore Gilbert D-KY
- George Pelton Lawrence R-MA
- Frederick Huntington Gillett R-MA
- John Randolph Thayer D-MA
- Charles Quincy Tirrell R-MA
- William Henry Moody R-MA
- Joseph Aloysius Conry D-MA
- William Stedman Greene R-MA
- William Humphreys Jackson R-MD
- Albert Alexander Blakeney R-MD
- Sydney Emanuel Mudd R-MD
- George Alexander Pearre R-MD
- Charles Edgar Littlefield R-ME
- Llewellyn Powers R-ME
- Washington Gardner R-MI
- Edward La Rue Hamilton R-MI
- Samuel William Smith R-MI
- Edgar Weeks R-MI
- Joseph Warren Fordney R-MI
- Roswell Peter Bishop R-MI
- Henry Harrison Aplin R-MI
- Archibald Bard Darragh R-MI
- James Albertus Tawney R-MN
- James Thompson Mccleary R-MN
- Joel Prescott Heatwole R-MN
- Frederick Clement Stevens R-MN
- Loren Fletcher R-MN
- Robert Page Walter Morris R-MN
- Frank Marion Eddy R-MN
- James Tilghman Lloyd D-MO
- John Dougherty D-MO
- David Albaugh De Armond D-MO
- James Cooney D-MO
- James Beauchamp (Champ) Clark D-MO
- Edward Robb D-MO
- Willard Duncan Vandiver D-MO
- Edward William Pou D-NC
- Edmond Spencer Blackburn R-NC
- James Montraville Moody R-NC
- Thomas Frank Marshall R-ND
- John Seaton Robinson D-NE
- William Ledyard Stark O-NE
- Ashton Cokayne Shallenberger D-NE
- Cyrus Adams Sulloway R-NH
- Frank Dunklee Currier R-NH
- John James Gardner R-NJ
- Benjamin Franklin Howell R-NJ
- Joshua S. Salmon D-NJ
- James Fleming Stewart R-NJ
- Richard Wayne Parker R-NJ
- Francis Griffith Newlands D-NV
- Henry Bristow R-NY
- George Henry Lindsay D-NY
- John Henry Ketcham R-NY
- William Henry Draper R-NY
- John Knox Stewart R-NY
- Lucius Nathan Littauer R-NY
- Louis Woodard Emerson R-NY
- Charles Luman Knapp R-NY
- James Schoolcraft Sherman R-NY
- George Washington Ray R-NY
- Michael Edward Driscoll R-NY
- Sereno Elisha Payne R-NY
- Charles William Gillet R-NY
- James Breck Perkins R-NY
- De Alva Stanwood Alexander R-NY
- Edward Butterfield Vreeland R-NY
- Robert Murphy Nevin R-OH
- Robert Bryarly Gordon D-OH
- John Stout Snook D-OH
- Charles Quinn Hildebrant R-OH
- William Robert Warnock R-OH
- Stephen Morgan R-OH
- Emmett Tompkins R-OH
- William Woodburn Skiles R-OH
- Henry Clay Van Voorhis R-OH
- Joseph John Gill R-OH
- John Wilson Cassingham D-OH
- Charles William Frederick Dick R-OH
- Thomas H. Tongue R-OR
- Malcolm Adelbert Moody R-OR
- Edward de Veaux Morrell R-PA
- Thomas Stalker Butler R-PA
- Irving Price Wanger R-PA
- Howard Mutchler D-PA
- Henry Dickinson Green D-PA
- Henry Burd Cassel R-PA
- George Robert Patterson R-PA
- Marlin Edgar Olmsted R-PA
- Charles Frederick Wright R-PA
- Elias Deemer R-PA
- Thaddeus Maclay Mahon R-PA
- Robert Jacob Lewis R-PA
- Alvin Evans R-PA
- Summers Melville Jack R-PA
- Ernest Francis Acheson R-PA
- Joseph Baltzell Showalter R-PA
- Arthur Laban Bates R-PA
- Joseph Crocker Sibley R-PA
- James Knox Polk Hall D-PA
- Galusha Aaron Grow R-PA
- Robert Hermann Foerderer R-PA
- Charles Henry Burke R-SD
- Eben Wever Martin R-SD
- Walter Preston Brownlow R-TN
- Henry Richard Gibson R-TN
- George Sutherland R-UT
- William Atkinson Jones D-VA
- John Lamb D-VA
- Peter Johnston Otey D-VA
- John Franklin Rixey D-VA
- David Johnson Foster R-VT
- Kittredge Haskins R-VT
- Francis Wellington Cushman R-WA
- Wesley Livsey Jones R-WA
- Henry Allen Cooper R-WI
- Herman Bjorn Dahle R-WI
- Joseph Weeks Babcock R-WI
- Samuel Stebbins Barney R-WI
- James Henry Davidson R-WI
- Edward Sloman Minor R-WI
- Webster Everett Brown R-WI
- John James Jenkins R-WI
- Blackburn Barrett Dovener R-WV
Did not vote
- George Washington Taylor D-AL
- John Hollis Bankhead D-AL
- Frank Bosworth Brandegee R-CT
- James Mathews Griggs D-GA
- Charles Lafayette Bartlett D-GA
- David Bremner Henderson R-IA
- Robert Gordon Cousins R-IA
- Walter Inglewood Smith R-IA
- Thomas Louis Glenn O-ID
- George Edmund Foss R-IL
- Albert Jarvis Hopkins R-IL
- Robert Roberts Hitt R-IL
- Walter Reeves R-IL
- Joseph Verdi Graff R-IL
- Joseph Burns Crowley D-IL
- James Alexander Hemenway R-IN
- Elias Selah Holliday R-IN
- George Washington Cromer R-IN
- Charles Beary Landis R-IN
- Abraham Lincoln Brick R-IN
- William Augustus Reeder R-KS
- Charles Frederick Scott R-KS
- John McKenzie Moss R-KY
- Harvey Samuel Irwin R-KY
- South Trimble D-KY
- Vincent Boreing R-KY
- Adolph Meyer D-LA
- Robert Foligny Broussard D-LA
- Phanor Breazeale D-LA
- William Shadrach Knox R-MA
- Augustus Peabody Gardner R-MA
- Ernest William Roberts R-MA
- Samuel Leland Powers R-MA
- Amos Lawrence Allen R-ME
- Edwin Chick Burleigh R-ME
- John Blaisdell Corliss R-MI
- Henry Cassorte Smith R-MI
- William Alden Smith R-MI
- Carlos Douglas Shelden R-MI
- Charles Fremont Cochran D-MO
- Dorsey William Shackleford D-MO
- Richard Bartholdt R-MO
- George Chester Robinson Wagoner R-MO
- Maecenas Eason Benton D-MO
- Thomas Spight D-MS
- Charles Randolph Thomas D-NC
- John Dillard Bellamy D-NC
- Theodore Franklin Kluttz D-NC
- Elmer Jacob Burkett R-NE
- David Henry Mercer R-NE
- William Neville O-NE
- De Witt Clinton Flanagan D-NJ
- Charles Newell Fowler R-NJ
- Frederic Storm R-NY
- John Joseph Fitzgerald D-NY
- Nicholas Muller D-NY
- Edward Swann D-NY
- William Sulzer D-NY
- Oliver Hazard Perry Belmont D-NY
- Cornelius Amory Pugsley D-NY
- Arthur Sidney Tompkins R-NY
- George Newell Southwick R-NY
- John Wilbur Dwight R-NY
- William Bunn Shattuc R-OH
- Thomas Barton Kyle R-OH
- James Harding Southard R-OH
- Charles Henry Grosvenor R-OH
- James Albert Norton D-OH
- Robert Walker Tayler R-OH
- Jacob Atlee Beidler R-OH
- Henry Harrison Bingham R-PA
- James Rankin Young R-PA
- Marriott Brosius R-PA
- Henry Wilbur Palmer R-PA
- Alexander Billmeyer D-PA
- Rufus King Polk D-PA
- William Harrison Graham R-PA
- Melville Bull R-RI
- Adin Ballou Capron R-RI
- David Edward Finley D-SC
- James William Stokes D-SC
- Gordon James Russell D-TX
- Morris Sheppard D-TX
- Claude Augustus Swanson D-VA
- Carter Glass D-VA
- James Hay D-VA
- William Francis Rhea D-VA
- Henry De La Warr Flood D-VA
- Theobald Otjen R-WI
- John Jacob Esch R-WI
- Alston Gordon Dayton R-WV
- Joseph Holt Gaines R-WV
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To recommit H.R. 9206 with instructions to…: House Vote, Feb 12, 1902,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/57-H-15/to-recommit-h-r-9206-with-instructions-to-report (accessed 2026-10-16).