House roll call 199 · 48th Congress · Dec 16, 1884
To pass a substitute bill, making it a penal offence to charge unreasonable rates; to discriminate against shippers, prohibiting any railroad from charging more
On Dec 16, 1884, the House voted 142–98. Result: passed. By party: Democrats 127–28, Republicans 17–70, Others 3–3. It was a split vote: the parties took opposite sides, with some members crossing over. 45 members voted against their own party.
During the 48th Congress (1883–1884), Chester A. Arthur was president, and Democrats held the House majority and Republicans the Senate majority.
- Yes
- 142
- No
- 98
- Did not vote
- 91
- Date
- Dec 16, 1884
By party
- Democrats127 yes · 28 no · 46 didn’t vote
- Republicans17 yes · 70 no · 37 didn’t vote
- Others3 yes · 3 no · 6 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- William Wallace Eaton D-CT voted no
- Charles Le Moyne Mitchell D-CT voted no
- Edward Woodruff Seymour D-CT voted no
- William Cullen R-IL voted yes
- Lewis Edwin Payson R-IL voted yes
- John Alexander Anderson R-KS voted yes
- John Daugherty White R-KY voted yes
- Leopold Morse D-MA voted no
- Joshua Frederick Cockey Talbott D-MD voted no
- Fetter Schrier Hoblitzell D-MD voted no
- John Van Lear Findlay D-MD voted no
- Louis Emory Mccomas R-MD voted yes
- Julius Houseman D-MI voted no
- Knute Nelson R-MN voted yes
- John Joseph O'Neill D-MO voted no
- Martin Linn Clardy D-MO voted no
- Archibald Jerard Weaver R-NE voted yes
- Darwin Rush James R-NY voted yes
- Abram Stevens Hewitt D-NY voted no
- Orlando Brunson Potter D-NY voted no
- Edward Wemple D-NY voted no
- George Washington Ray R-NY voted yes
- Charles Rufus Skinner R-NY voted yes
- Newton Wright Nutting R-NY voted yes
- Stephen Columbus Millard R-NY voted yes
- Halbert Stevens Greenleaf D-NY voted no
- Robert Smith Stevens D-NY voted no
- Frank Hunt Hurd D-OH voted no
- Alphonso Hart R-OH voted yes
- George Leroy Converse D-OH voted no
- Adoniram Judson Warner D-OH voted no
- David Raymond Paige D-OH voted no
- William Mutchler D-PA voted no
- Jacob Miller Campbell R-PA voted yes
- Charles Edmund Boyle D-PA voted no
- Mortimer Fitzland Elliott D-PA voted no
- Samuel Dibble D-SC voted no
- George Dionysius Tillman D-SC voted no
- George William Dargan D-SC voted no
- Robert Smalls R-SC voted yes
- Augustus Herman Pettibone R-TN voted yes
- Peter Victor Deuster D-WI voted no
- Joseph Rankin D-WI voted no
- Gilbert Motier Woodward D-WI voted no
- Nathan Goff R-WV voted yes
How each representative voted: Yes
- James Taylor Jones D-AL
- Hilary Abner Herbert D-AL
- William Calvin Oates D-AL
- Thomas Williams D-AL
- Goldsmith Whitehouse Hewitt D-AL
- William Henry Forney D-AL
- Luke Pryor D-AL
- Poindexter Dunn D-AR
- James Kimbrough Jones D-AR
- John Henry Rogers D-AR
- Samuel West Peel D-AR
- Clifton Rodes Breckinridge D-AR
- William Starke Rosecrans D-CA
- Barclay Henley D-CA
- Pleasant Britton Tully D-CA
- Charles Allen Sumner D-CA
- John Raglan Glascock D-CA
- Charles Brown Lore D-DE
- Robert Hamilton McWhorta Davidson D-FL
- John Calhoun Nicholls D-GA
- Henry Gray Turner D-GA
- Charles Frederick Crisp D-GA
- Hugh Buchanan D-GA
- James Henderson Blount D-GA
- Judson Claudius Clements D-GA
- Seaborn Reese D-GA
- Allen Daniel Candler D-GA
- Thomas Hardeman Jr. D-GA
- Jeremiah Henry Murphy D-IA
- John Calhoun Cook D-IA
- William Cullen R-IL
- Lewis Edwin Payson R-IL
- Nicholas Ellsworth Worthington D-IL
- William Henry Neece D-IL
- James Milton Riggs D-IL
- William McKendree Springer D-IL
- Samuel Wheeler Moulton D-IL
- William Ralls Morrison D-IL
- Richard Wellington Townshend D-IL
- John Jay Kleiner D-IN
- Thomas Reed Cobb D-IN
- Strother Madison Stockslager D-IN
- William Steele Holman D-IN
- Courtland Cushing Matson D-IN
- William Eastin English D-IN
- John Edward Lamb D-IN
- Thomas Bayless Ward D-IN
- Thomas Jefferson Wood D-IN
- Robert Lowry D-IN
- Benjamin Franklin Shively O-IN
- John Alexander Anderson R-KS
- Oscar Turner O-KY
- James Franklin Clay D-KY
- John Edward Halsell D-KY
- Thomas Austin Robertson D-KY
- Albert Shelby Willis D-KY
- Philip Burton Thompson Jr. D-KY
- John Daugherty White R-KY
- Frank Lane Wolford D-KY
- Carleton Hunt D-LA
- Newton Crain Blanchard D-LA
- Edward Taylor Lewis D-LA
- Patrick Andrew Collins D-MA
- Henry Bacon Lovering D-MA
- Louis Emory Mccomas R-MD
- Nathaniel Buel Eldredge D-MI
- George Lewis Yaple D-MI
- Edwin Baruch Winans D-MI
- Ezra Child Carleton D-MI
- Knute Nelson R-MN
- William Henry Hatch D-MO
- Armstead Milton Alexander D-MO
- Alexander Monroe Dockery D-MO
- James Nelson Burnes D-MO
- John Cosgrove D-MO
- Aylett Hawes Buckner D-MO
- Robert Washington Fyan D-MO
- Lowndes Henry Davis D-MO
- Henry Lowndes Muldrow D-MS
- Otho Robards Singleton D-MS
- Henry Smith Van Eaton D-MS
- Ethelbert Barksdale D-MS
- Thomas Gregory Skinner D-NC
- Wharton Jackson Green D-NC
- William Ruffin Cox D-NC
- Alfred Moore Scales D-NC
- Clement Dowd D-NC
- Tyre York O-NC
- Risden Tyler Bennett D-NC
- Archibald Jerard Weaver R-NE
- Thomas Merrill Ferrell D-NJ
- William Mcadoo D-NJ
- Darwin Rush James R-NY
- Samuel Sullivan Cox D-NY
- Lewis Beach D-NY
- John Holroyd Bagley Jr. D-NY
- Thomas Jefferson Van Alstyne D-NY
- George Washington Ray R-NY
- Charles Rufus Skinner R-NY
- Newton Wright Nutting R-NY
- Stephen Columbus Millard R-NY
- William Findlay Rogers D-NY
- Isaac M. Jordan D-OH
- Robert Maynard Murray D-OH
- Benjamin Le Fevre D-OH
- James Edwin Campbell D-OH
- Alphonso Hart R-OH
- George Washington Geddes D-OH
- Beriah Wilkins D-OH
- Jonathan Hasson Wallace D-OH
- Martin Ambrose Foran D-OH
- Samuel Jackson Randall D-PA
- John Brutzman Storm D-PA
- Jacob Miller Campbell R-PA
- James Herron Hopkins D-PA
- John Denniston Patton D-PA
- John Bratton D-SC
- John James Hemphill D-SC
- Robert Smalls R-SC
- Augustus Herman Pettibone R-TN
- George Gibbs Dibrell D-TN
- Benton Mcmillin D-TN
- Richard Warner D-TN
- Andrew Jackson Caldwell D-TN
- John Goff Ballentine D-TN
- John May Taylor D-TN
- Rice Alexander Pierce D-TN
- Charles Stewart D-TX
- John Henninger Reagan D-TX
- James Henry Jones D-TX
- David Browning Culberson D-TX
- James Webb Throckmorton D-TX
- Olin Wellborn D-TX
- James Francis Miller D-TX
- Roger Quarles Mills D-TX
- John Hancock D-TX
- Samuel Willis Tucker Lanham D-TX
- George Douglas Wise D-VA
- George Craighead Cabell D-VA
- John Randolph Tucker D-VA
- Charles Triplett O'Ferrall D-VA
- John Winans D-WI
- Burr W. Jones D-WI
- Nathan Goff R-WV
- William Lyne Wilson D-WV
- Charles Philip Snyder D-WV
- Eustace Gibson D-WV
How each representative voted: No
- William Wallace Eaton D-CT
- Charles Le Moyne Mitchell D-CT
- John Turner Wait R-CT
- Edward Woodruff Seymour D-CT
- Moses Ayers Mccoid R-IA
- David Bremner Henderson R-IA
- James Wilson R-IA
- Hiram Ypsilanti Smith R-IA
- William Peters Hepburn R-IA
- Adoniram Judson Holmes R-IA
- Isaac S. Struble R-IA
- John Frederick Finerty O-IL
- George Royal Davis R-IL
- George Everett Adams R-IL
- Robert Roberts Hitt R-IL
- Thomas Jefferson Henderson R-IL
- Jonathan Harvey Rowell R-IL
- Joseph Gurney Cannon R-IL
- John Robert Thomas R-IL
- Thomas McLelland Browne R-IN
- Edward Hogue Funston R-KS
- Thomas Ryan R-KS
- Bishop Walden Perkins R-KS
- Edmund Needham Morrill R-KS
- Lewis Hanback R-KS
- Samuel Ritter Peters R-KS
- William Wirt Culbertson R-KY
- Robert Thompson Davis R-MA
- John Davis Long R-MA
- Ambrose Arnold Ranney R-MA
- Leopold Morse D-MA
- Theodore Lyman O-MA
- William Whitney Rice R-MA
- William Whiting R-MA
- Francis Williams Rockwell R-MA
- Joshua Frederick Cockey Talbott D-MD
- Fetter Schrier Hoblitzell D-MD
- John Van Lear Findlay D-MD
- Hart Benton Holton R-MD
- Charles Addison Boutelle R-ME
- Seth Llewellyn Milliken R-ME
- Thomas Brackett Reed R-ME
- Edward Samuel Lacey R-MI
- Julius Houseman D-MI
- Roswell Gilbert Horr R-MI
- Byron M. Cutcheon R-MI
- Herschel Harrison Hatch R-MI
- Edward Breitung R-MI
- Milo White R-MN
- James Beach Wakefield R-MN
- Horace Burton Strait R-MN
- William Drew Washburn R-MN
- John Joseph O'Neill D-MO
- Martin Linn Clardy D-MO
- James Edward O'Hara R-NC
- James Laird R-NE
- Martin Alonzo Haynes R-NH
- John Hart Brewer R-NJ
- John Kean R-NJ
- William Walter Phelps R-NJ
- Abram Stevens Hewitt D-NY
- Orlando Brunson Potter D-NY
- Frederick Avery Johnson R-NY
- Abraham X. Parker R-NY
- Edward Wemple D-NY
- Frank Hiscock R-NY
- Sereno Elisha Payne R-NY
- James Wolcott Wadsworth R-NY
- Halbert Stevens Greenleaf D-NY
- Robert Smith Stevens D-NY
- Francis Beattie Brewer R-NY
- Joseph Warren Keifer R-OH
- James Sidney Robinson R-OH
- Frank Hunt Hurd D-OH
- George Leroy Converse D-OH
- Adoniram Judson Warner D-OH
- Ezra Booth Taylor R-OH
- David Raymond Paige D-OH
- Charles O'Neill R-PA
- Alfred Crout Harmer R-PA
- James Bowen Everhart R-PA
- Isaac Newton Evans R-PA
- Abraham Herr Smith R-PA
- William Mutchler D-PA
- Samuel Fleming Barr R-PA
- William Wallace Brown R-PA
- Louis Evans Atkinson R-PA
- Charles Edmund Boyle D-PA
- George Van Eman Lawrence R-PA
- Samuel Myron Brainerd R-PA
- Mortimer Fitzland Elliott D-PA
- Jonathan Chace R-RI
- Samuel Dibble D-SC
- George Dionysius Tillman D-SC
- George William Dargan D-SC
- Harry Libbey O-VA
- John Wolcott Stewart R-VT
- Peter Victor Deuster D-WI
- Joseph Rankin D-WI
- Gilbert Motier Woodward D-WI
- Isaac Stephenson R-WI
Did not vote
- Charles Miller Shelley D-AL
- George Henry Craig R-AL
- James Herbert Budd D-CA
- James Burns Belford R-CO
- Horatio Bisbee Jr. R-FL
- Nathaniel Job Hammond D-GA
- Luman Hamlin Weller O-IA
- John Adam Kasson R-IA
- William Henry Mills Pusey D-IA
- Ransom Williams Dunham R-IL
- Reuben Ellwood R-IL
- Aaron Shaw D-IL
- Stanton Judkins Peelle R-IN
- George Washington Steele R-IN
- William Henry Calkins R-IN
- Dudley Chase Haskell R-KS
- John Griffin Carlisle D-KY
- Joseph Clay Stiles Blackburn D-KY
- Ezekiel John Ellis D-LA
- William Pitt Kellogg R-LA
- John Floyd King D-LA
- Eben Francis Stone R-MA
- William Augustus Russell R-MA
- George Dexter Robinson R-MA
- George Washington Covington D-MD
- Nelson Dingley Jr. R-ME
- William Cotter Maybury D-MI
- Alexander Graves D-MO
- James Overton Broadhead D-MO
- Richard Parks Bland D-MO
- Charles Henry Morgan D-MO
- James Ronald Chalmers I-MS
- Elza Jeffords R-MS
- Hernando De Soto Money D-MS
- James Wesley Reid D-NC
- Robert Brank Vance D-NC
- Edward Kimble Valentine R-NE
- Ossian Ray R-NH
- Benjamin Franklin Howey R-NJ
- William Henry Frederick Fiedler D-NJ
- George Williams Cassidy D-NV
- Perry Belmont D-NY
- William Erigena Robinson D-NY
- Felix Campbell D-NY
- Nicholas Muller D-NY
- William Dorsheimer D-NY
- John Joseph Adams D-NY
- John Hardy D-NY
- Waldo Hutchins D-NY
- John Henry Ketcham R-NY
- Henry Gordon Burleigh R-NY
- John Thomas Spriggs D-NY
- John Arnot Jr. D-NY
- Henry Warner Slocum D-NY
- John Fassett Follett D-OH
- George Ebbert Seney D-OH
- William David Hill D-OH
- Henry Lee Morey R-OH
- John Watts Mccormick R-OH
- Joseph Danner Taylor R-OH
- William Mckinley Jr. R-OH
- Melvin Clark George R-OR
- Henry Harrison Bingham R-PA
- William Darrah Kelley R-PA
- Daniel Ermentrout D-PA
- Daniel Ward Connolly D-PA
- Charles Napoleon Brumm O-PA
- George Adams Post D-PA
- John Augustus Swope D-PA
- William Addison Duncan D-PA
- Andrew Gregg Curtin D-PA
- Thomas McKee Bayne R-PA
- Samuel Henry Miller R-PA
- Henry Joshua Spooner R-RI
- Nathan Fellows Dixon R-RI
- David Wyatt Aiken D-SC
- John Hamilton Evins D-SC
- Edmund William McGregor Mackey R-SC
- Leonidas Campbell Houk R-TN
- Hiram Casey Young D-TN
- Thomas Peck Ochiltree I-TX
- George Tankard Garrison D-VA
- Robert Murphy Mayo O-VA
- Benjamin Stephen Hooper O-VA
- John Strode Barbour Jr. D-VA
- Henry Bowen O-VA
- John Sergeant Wise O-VA
- Luke Potter Poland R-VT
- Daniel Hadley Sumner D-WI
- Richard William Guenther R-WI
- William Thompson Price R-WI
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To pass a substitute bill, making it a penal…: House Vote, Dec 16…,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/48-H-199/to-pass-a-substitute-bill-making-it-a-penal (accessed 2026-10-16).