House roll call 18 · 48th Congress · Feb 8, 1884
To recommit a resolution to the committee on rules with instructions requiring the committee to report two rules on motions, one, that only a committee may dire
On Feb 8, 1884, the House voted 113–130. Result: failed. By party: Democrats 28–124, Republicans 79–6, Others 7–2. It was a split vote: the parties took opposite sides, with some members crossing over. 34 members voted against their own party.
During the 48th Congress (1883–1884), Chester A. Arthur was president, and Democrats held the House majority and Republicans the Senate majority.
- Yes
- 113
- No
- 130
- Did not vote
- 93
- Date
- Feb 8, 1884
By party
- Democrats28 yes · 124 no · 49 didn’t vote
- Republicans79 yes · 6 no · 39 didn’t vote
- Others7 yes · 2 no · 3 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- Hilary Abner Herbert D-AL voted yes
- William Calvin Oates D-AL voted yes
- Goldsmith Whitehouse Hewitt D-AL voted yes
- James Herbert Budd D-CA voted yes
- John Calhoun Cook D-IA voted yes
- Nicholas Ellsworth Worthington D-IL voted yes
- Joseph Gurney Cannon R-IL voted no
- John Alexander Anderson R-KS voted no
- Carleton Hunt D-LA voted yes
- Patrick Andrew Collins D-MA voted yes
- Henry Bacon Lovering D-MA voted yes
- Nathaniel Buel Eldredge D-MI voted yes
- Aylett Hawes Buckner D-MO voted yes
- Martin Linn Clardy D-MO voted yes
- Richard Parks Bland D-MO voted yes
- Charles Henry Morgan D-MO voted yes
- Henry Lowndes Muldrow D-MS voted yes
- Robert Brank Vance D-NC voted yes
- Lewis Beach D-NY voted yes
- Frank Hiscock R-NY voted no
- Halbert Stevens Greenleaf D-NY voted yes
- William Findlay Rogers D-NY voted yes
- Alfred Crout Harmer R-PA voted no
- Abraham Herr Smith R-PA voted no
- Thomas McKee Bayne R-PA voted no
- David Wyatt Aiken D-SC voted yes
- Charles Stewart D-TX voted yes
- John Henninger Reagan D-TX voted yes
- James Henry Jones D-TX voted yes
- James Webb Throckmorton D-TX voted yes
- Roger Quarles Mills D-TX voted yes
- John Hancock D-TX voted yes
- Samuel Willis Tucker Lanham D-TX voted yes
- Gilbert Motier Woodward D-WI voted yes
How each representative voted: Yes
- Hilary Abner Herbert D-AL
- William Calvin Oates D-AL
- Goldsmith Whitehouse Hewitt D-AL
- James Herbert Budd D-CA
- John Turner Wait R-CT
- David Bremner Henderson R-IA
- Luman Hamlin Weller O-IA
- James Wilson R-IA
- John Calhoun Cook D-IA
- William Peters Hepburn R-IA
- Isaac S. Struble R-IA
- John Frederick Finerty O-IL
- George Royal Davis R-IL
- George Everett Adams R-IL
- Reuben Ellwood R-IL
- Robert Roberts Hitt R-IL
- Thomas Jefferson Henderson R-IL
- William Cullen R-IL
- Lewis Edwin Payson R-IL
- Nicholas Ellsworth Worthington D-IL
- Jonathan Harvey Rowell R-IL
- Stanton Judkins Peelle R-IN
- George Washington Steele R-IN
- William Henry Calkins R-IN
- Thomas Ryan R-KS
- Bishop Walden Perkins R-KS
- Lewis Hanback R-KS
- Samuel Ritter Peters R-KS
- William Wirt Culbertson R-KY
- Carleton Hunt D-LA
- Robert Thompson Davis R-MA
- John Davis Long R-MA
- Ambrose Arnold Ranney R-MA
- Patrick Andrew Collins D-MA
- Henry Bacon Lovering D-MA
- Eben Francis Stone R-MA
- William Augustus Russell R-MA
- Theodore Lyman O-MA
- William Whiting R-MA
- Francis Williams Rockwell R-MA
- Charles Addison Boutelle R-ME
- Nelson Dingley Jr. R-ME
- Thomas Brackett Reed R-ME
- Nathaniel Buel Eldredge D-MI
- Edward Samuel Lacey R-MI
- Roswell Gilbert Horr R-MI
- Byron M. Cutcheon R-MI
- Herschel Harrison Hatch R-MI
- Edward Breitung R-MI
- Milo White R-MN
- James Beach Wakefield R-MN
- Horace Burton Strait R-MN
- William Drew Washburn R-MN
- Knute Nelson R-MN
- Aylett Hawes Buckner D-MO
- Martin Linn Clardy D-MO
- Richard Parks Bland D-MO
- Charles Henry Morgan D-MO
- Henry Lowndes Muldrow D-MS
- Elza Jeffords R-MS
- James Edward O'Hara R-NC
- Robert Brank Vance D-NC
- Archibald Jerard Weaver R-NE
- Martin Alonzo Haynes R-NH
- Ossian Ray R-NH
- John Kean R-NJ
- William Walter Phelps R-NJ
- Lewis Beach D-NY
- Henry Gordon Burleigh R-NY
- Frederick Avery Johnson R-NY
- Abraham X. Parker R-NY
- George Washington Ray R-NY
- Charles Rufus Skinner R-NY
- Sereno Elisha Payne R-NY
- James Wolcott Wadsworth R-NY
- Stephen Columbus Millard R-NY
- Halbert Stevens Greenleaf D-NY
- William Findlay Rogers D-NY
- Francis Beattie Brewer R-NY
- Henry Lee Morey R-OH
- Joseph Warren Keifer R-OH
- John Watts Mccormick R-OH
- Alphonso Hart R-OH
- Joseph Danner Taylor R-OH
- William Mckinley Jr. R-OH
- Ezra Booth Taylor R-OH
- Melvin Clark George R-OR
- William Darrah Kelley R-PA
- James Bowen Everhart R-PA
- William Wallace Brown R-PA
- Jacob Miller Campbell R-PA
- Louis Evans Atkinson R-PA
- George Van Eman Lawrence R-PA
- Samuel Myron Brainerd R-PA
- Jonathan Chace R-RI
- David Wyatt Aiken D-SC
- Augustus Herman Pettibone R-TN
- Charles Stewart D-TX
- John Henninger Reagan D-TX
- James Henry Jones D-TX
- James Webb Throckmorton D-TX
- Roger Quarles Mills D-TX
- John Hancock D-TX
- Samuel Willis Tucker Lanham D-TX
- Robert Murphy Mayo O-VA
- Harry Libbey O-VA
- Henry Bowen O-VA
- John Sergeant Wise O-VA
- John Wolcott Stewart R-VT
- Luke Potter Poland R-VT
- Gilbert Motier Woodward D-WI
- William Thompson Price R-WI
- Isaac Stephenson R-WI
- Nathan Goff R-WV
How each representative voted: No
- James Taylor Jones D-AL
- Thomas Williams D-AL
- William Henry Forney D-AL
- Luke Pryor D-AL
- James Kimbrough Jones D-AR
- John Henry Rogers D-AR
- Samuel West Peel D-AR
- Clifton Rodes Breckinridge D-AR
- Barclay Henley D-CA
- Pleasant Britton Tully D-CA
- Charles Allen Sumner D-CA
- John Raglan Glascock D-CA
- William Wallace Eaton D-CT
- Charles Le Moyne Mitchell D-CT
- Edward Woodruff Seymour D-CT
- Charles Brown Lore D-DE
- Robert Hamilton McWhorta Davidson D-FL
- John Calhoun Nicholls D-GA
- Henry Gray Turner D-GA
- Charles Frederick Crisp D-GA
- Hugh Buchanan D-GA
- James Henderson Blount D-GA
- Judson Claudius Clements D-GA
- Seaborn Reese D-GA
- Allen Daniel Candler D-GA
- Thomas Hardeman Jr. D-GA
- William Henry Mills Pusey D-IA
- William Henry Neece D-IL
- James Milton Riggs D-IL
- William McKendree Springer D-IL
- Joseph Gurney Cannon R-IL
- Aaron Shaw D-IL
- Samuel Wheeler Moulton D-IL
- William Ralls Morrison D-IL
- Richard Wellington Townshend D-IL
- John Jay Kleiner D-IN
- Thomas Reed Cobb D-IN
- Strother Madison Stockslager D-IN
- William Steele Holman D-IN
- Courtland Cushing Matson D-IN
- John Edward Lamb D-IN
- Thomas Bayless Ward D-IN
- Thomas Jefferson Wood D-IN
- Robert Lowry D-IN
- John Alexander Anderson R-KS
- Oscar Turner O-KY
- James Franklin Clay D-KY
- John Edward Halsell D-KY
- Philip Burton Thompson Jr. D-KY
- Frank Lane Wolford D-KY
- Ezekiel John Ellis D-LA
- John Floyd King D-LA
- Edward Taylor Lewis D-LA
- Leopold Morse D-MA
- George Washington Covington D-MD
- Joshua Frederick Cockey Talbott D-MD
- Fetter Schrier Hoblitzell D-MD
- William Cotter Maybury D-MI
- George Lewis Yaple D-MI
- Julius Houseman D-MI
- Edwin Baruch Winans D-MI
- Ezra Child Carleton D-MI
- William Henry Hatch D-MO
- Armstead Milton Alexander D-MO
- Alexander Monroe Dockery D-MO
- Alexander Graves D-MO
- John Cosgrove D-MO
- Robert Washington Fyan D-MO
- Lowndes Henry Davis D-MO
- Ethelbert Barksdale D-MS
- Thomas Gregory Skinner D-NC
- Alfred Moore Scales D-NC
- Clement Dowd D-NC
- Tyre York O-NC
- Risden Tyler Bennett D-NC
- Thomas Merrill Ferrell D-NJ
- William Henry Frederick Fiedler D-NJ
- William Mcadoo D-NJ
- George Williams Cassidy D-NV
- William Erigena Robinson D-NY
- Felix Campbell D-NY
- Nicholas Muller D-NY
- John Hardy D-NY
- Orlando Brunson Potter D-NY
- John Holroyd Bagley Jr. D-NY
- Thomas Jefferson Van Alstyne D-NY
- Frank Hiscock R-NY
- John Arnot Jr. D-NY
- Robert Smith Stevens D-NY
- Henry Warner Slocum D-NY
- John Fassett Follett D-OH
- Isaac M. Jordan D-OH
- Robert Maynard Murray D-OH
- George Leroy Converse D-OH
- George Washington Geddes D-OH
- Beriah Wilkins D-OH
- David Raymond Paige D-OH
- Samuel Jackson Randall D-PA
- Alfred Crout Harmer R-PA
- Daniel Ermentrout D-PA
- Abraham Herr Smith R-PA
- William Mutchler D-PA
- Daniel Ward Connolly D-PA
- William Addison Duncan D-PA
- Andrew Gregg Curtin D-PA
- Charles Edmund Boyle D-PA
- James Herron Hopkins D-PA
- Thomas McKee Bayne R-PA
- John Denniston Patton D-PA
- Mortimer Fitzland Elliott D-PA
- Samuel Dibble D-SC
- George Dionysius Tillman D-SC
- John Hamilton Evins D-SC
- John James Hemphill D-SC
- George William Dargan D-SC
- George Gibbs Dibrell D-TN
- Benton Mcmillin D-TN
- Richard Warner D-TN
- John Goff Ballentine D-TN
- John May Taylor D-TN
- Rice Alexander Pierce D-TN
- Olin Wellborn D-TX
- James Francis Miller D-TX
- George Craighead Cabell D-VA
- John Strode Barbour Jr. D-VA
- John Winans D-WI
- Daniel Hadley Sumner D-WI
- Burr W. Jones D-WI
- Joseph Rankin D-WI
- William Lyne Wilson D-WV
- Charles Philip Snyder D-WV
- Eustace Gibson D-WV
Did not vote
- Charles Miller Shelley D-AL
- George Henry Craig R-AL
- Poindexter Dunn D-AR
- William Starke Rosecrans D-CA
- James Burns Belford R-CO
- Horatio Bisbee Jr. R-FL
- Nathaniel Job Hammond D-GA
- Moses Ayers Mccoid R-IA
- Jeremiah Henry Murphy D-IA
- Hiram Ypsilanti Smith R-IA
- John Adam Kasson R-IA
- Adoniram Judson Holmes R-IA
- Ransom Williams Dunham R-IL
- John Robert Thomas R-IL
- Thomas McLelland Browne R-IN
- William Eastin English D-IN
- Benjamin Franklin Shively O-IN
- Dudley Chase Haskell R-KS
- Edward Hogue Funston R-KS
- Edmund Needham Morrill R-KS
- Thomas Austin Robertson D-KY
- Albert Shelby Willis D-KY
- John Griffin Carlisle D-KY
- Joseph Clay Stiles Blackburn D-KY
- John Daugherty White R-KY
- William Pitt Kellogg R-LA
- Newton Crain Blanchard D-LA
- William Whitney Rice R-MA
- George Dexter Robinson R-MA
- John Van Lear Findlay D-MD
- Hart Benton Holton R-MD
- Louis Emory Mccomas R-MD
- Seth Llewellyn Milliken R-ME
- James Nelson Burnes D-MO
- John Joseph O'Neill D-MO
- James Overton Broadhead D-MO
- James Ronald Chalmers I-MS
- Hernando De Soto Money D-MS
- Otho Robards Singleton D-MS
- Henry Smith Van Eaton D-MS
- Wharton Jackson Green D-NC
- William Ruffin Cox D-NC
- James Wesley Reid D-NC
- James Laird R-NE
- Edward Kimble Valentine R-NE
- John Hart Brewer R-NJ
- Benjamin Franklin Howey R-NJ
- Perry Belmont D-NY
- Darwin Rush James R-NY
- Samuel Sullivan Cox D-NY
- William Dorsheimer D-NY
- John Joseph Adams D-NY
- Abram Stevens Hewitt D-NY
- Waldo Hutchins D-NY
- John Henry Ketcham R-NY
- Edward Wemple D-NY
- John Thomas Spriggs D-NY
- Newton Wright Nutting R-NY
- Benjamin Le Fevre D-OH
- George Ebbert Seney D-OH
- William David Hill D-OH
- James Edwin Campbell D-OH
- James Sidney Robinson R-OH
- Frank Hunt Hurd D-OH
- Adoniram Judson Warner D-OH
- Jonathan Hasson Wallace D-OH
- Martin Ambrose Foran D-OH
- Henry Harrison Bingham R-PA
- Charles O'Neill R-PA
- Isaac Newton Evans R-PA
- John Brutzman Storm D-PA
- Charles Napoleon Brumm O-PA
- Samuel Fleming Barr R-PA
- George Adams Post D-PA
- John Augustus Swope D-PA
- Samuel Henry Miller R-PA
- Henry Joshua Spooner R-RI
- Nathan Fellows Dixon R-RI
- John Bratton D-SC
- Edmund William McGregor Mackey R-SC
- Robert Smalls R-SC
- Leonidas Campbell Houk R-TN
- Andrew Jackson Caldwell D-TN
- Hiram Casey Young D-TN
- David Browning Culberson D-TX
- Thomas Peck Ochiltree I-TX
- George Tankard Garrison D-VA
- George Douglas Wise D-VA
- Benjamin Stephen Hooper O-VA
- John Randolph Tucker D-VA
- Charles Triplett O'Ferrall D-VA
- Peter Victor Deuster D-WI
- Richard William Guenther R-WI
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To recommit a resolution to the committee on…: House Vote, Feb 8, 1884,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/48-H-18/to-recommit-a-resolution-to-the-committee-on-rules (accessed 2026-10-14).