Senate roll call 142 · 35th Congress · Mar 31, 1858
To amend S. 86 in the nature of a substitute for second section, which substitute provides that until new census be taken the state shall be entitled to three (
On Mar 31, 1858, the Senate voted 14–36 (S 86). Result: failed. By party: Democrats 14–14, Republicans 0–18, Others 0–4. It was a split vote: the parties took opposite sides, with some members crossing over. 14 members voted against their own party.
During the 35th Congress (1857–1858), James Buchanan was president, and Democrats held majorities in both the House and Senate.
- Yes
- 14
- No
- 36
- Did not vote
- 23
- Date
- Mar 31, 1858
By party
- Democrats14 yes · 14 no · 19 didn’t vote
- Republicans0 yes · 18 no · 3 didn’t vote
- Others0 yes · 4 no · 1 didn’t vote
Who broke with their party
- Benjamin Fitzpatrick D-AL voted no
- Clement Claiborne Clay Jr. D-AL voted no
- David Colbreth Broderick D-CA voted no
- James Asheton Bayard Jr. D-DE voted no
- Judah Philip Benjamin D-LA voted no
- James Alfred Pearce D-MD voted no
- Albert Gallatin Brown D-MS voted no
- Asa Biggs D-NC voted no
- John Renshaw Thomson D-NJ voted no
- James Henry Hammond D-SC voted no
- Josiah James Evans D-SC voted no
- Andrew Johnson D-TN voted no
- James Pinckney Henderson D-TX voted no
- James Murray Mason D-VA voted no
How each senator voted: Yes
- William King Sebastian D-AR
- William McKendree Gwin D-CA
- David Levy Yulee D-FL
- Alfred Iverson Sr. D-GA
- George Wallace Jones D-IA
- Graham Newell Fitch D-IN
- Jesse David Bright D-IN
- Charles Edward Stuart D-MI
- James Stephen Green D-MO
- Trusten Polk D-MO
- William Wright D-NJ
- George Ellis Pugh D-OH
- William Bigler D-PA
- Philip Allen D-RI
How each senator voted: No
- Benjamin Fitzpatrick D-AL
- Clement Claiborne Clay Jr. D-AL
- David Colbreth Broderick D-CA
- James Dixon R-CT
- Lafayette Sabine Foster R-CT
- James Asheton Bayard Jr. D-DE
- James Harlan R-IA
- Lyman Trumbull R-IL
- John Burton Thompson O-KY
- John Jordan Crittenden O-KY
- Judah Philip Benjamin D-LA
- Henry Wilson R-MA
- Anthony Kennedy O-MD
- James Alfred Pearce D-MD
- Hannibal Hamlin R-ME
- William Pitt Fessenden R-ME
- Zachariah Chandler R-MI
- Albert Gallatin Brown D-MS
- Asa Biggs D-NC
- Daniel Clark R-NH
- John Parker Hale R-NH
- John Renshaw Thomson D-NJ
- Preston King R-NY
- Benjamin Franklin Wade R-OH
- Simon Cameron R-PA
- James Fowler Simmons R-RI
- James Henry Hammond D-SC
- Josiah James Evans D-SC
- Andrew Johnson D-TN
- James Pinckney Henderson D-TX
- Samuel Houston O-TX
- James Murray Mason D-VA
- Jacob Collamer R-VT
- Solomon Foot R-VT
- Charles Durkee R-WI
- James Rood Doolittle R-WI
Did not vote
- Robert Ward Johnson D-AR
- Martin Waltham Bates D-DE
- Stephen Russell Mallory D-FL
- Robert Augustus Toombs D-GA
- Stephen Arnold Douglas D-IL
- John Slidell D-LA
- Charles Sumner R-MA
- Henry Mower Rice D-MN
- James Shields D-MN
- Jefferson Davis D-MS
- David Settle Reid D-NC
- Thomas Lanier Clingman D-NC
- James Bell R-NH
- William Henry Seward R-NY
- Delazon Smith D-OR
- Joseph Lane D-OR
- Andrew Pickens Butler D-SC
- Arthur Peronneau Hayne D-SC
- James Chesnut Jr. D-SC
- John Bell O-TN
- Matthias Ward D-TX
- Thomas Jefferson Rusk D-TX
- Robert Mercer Taliaferro Hunter D-VA
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To amend S. 86 in the nature of a substitute…: Senate Vote, Mar 31…,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/35-S-142/to-amend-s-86-in-the-nature-of-a (accessed 2026-10-17).