House roll call 1 · 11th Congress · May 23, 1809
To amend the resolution to appoint committees by adding words, "by ballot," so that the members instead of the speaker select the house committees.
On May 23, 1809, the House voted 41–67. Result: failed. By party: Others 41–67.
During the 11th Congress (1809–1810), James Madison was president.
- Yes
- 41
- No
- 67
- Did not vote
- 46
- Date
- May 23, 1809
By party
- Others41 yes · 67 no · 46 didn’t vote
How each representative voted: Yes
- Howell Cobb O-GA
- William Wyatt Bibb O-GA
- Matthew Lyon O-KY
- Laban Wheaton O-MA
- John Campbell O-MD
- Archibald Van Horne O-MD
- Philip Barton Key O-MD
- Lemuel Sawyer O-NC
- John Stanly O-NC
- Thomas Kenan O-NC
- Archibald Mcbryde O-NC
- Richard Stanford O-NC
- James Cochran O-NC
- Joseph Pearson O-NC
- James Holland O-NC
- Daniel Blaisdell O-NH
- John Curtis Chamberlain O-NH
- Nathaniel Appleton Haven O-NH
- James Emott O-NY
- Barent Gardenier O-NY
- Herman Knickerbocker O-NY
- Robert Le Roy Livingston O-NY
- Killian Killian Van Rensselaer O-NY
- Thomas Ruggles Gold O-NY
- Vincent Mathews O-NY
- William Milnor O-PA
- Daniel Hiester O-PA
- Robert Jenkins O-PA
- Samuel Smith O-PA
- Pleasant Moorman Miller O-TN
- James Stephenson O-VA
- Daniel Sheffey O-VA
- Joseph Lewis Jr. O-VA
- Walter Jones O-VA
- John Dawson O-VA
- Burwell Bassett O-VA
- Matthew Clay O-VA
- John Randolph O-VA
- John Wayles Eppes O-VA
- Edwin Gray O-VA
- William Chamberlain O-VT
How each representative voted: No
- Benjamin Tallmadge O-CT
- Epaphroditus Champion O-CT
- Lewis Burr Sturges O-CT
- Samuel Mckee O-KY
- Henry Crist O-KY
- Richard Mentor Johnson O-KY
- Benjamin Howard O-KY
- Joseph Desha O-KY
- Josiah Quincy O-MA
- Benjamin Pickman Jr. O-MA
- Samuel Taggart O-MA
- Gideon Gardner O-MA
- William Stedman O-MA
- Ezekiel Bacon O-MA
- Ebenezer Seaver O-MA
- Richard Cutts O-MA
- Barzillai Gannett O-MA
- Roger Nelson O-MD
- John Montgomery O-MD
- John Brown O-MD
- Willis Alston O-NC
- William Kennedy O-NC
- Nathaniel Macon O-NC
- Meshack Franklin O-NC
- Adam Boyd O-NJ
- Henry Southard O-NJ
- Jacob Hufty O-NJ
- James Cox O-NJ
- Thomas Newbold O-NJ
- Ebenezer Sage O-NY
- Jonathan Fisk O-NY
- John Thompson O-NY
- Thomas Sammons O-NY
- John Nicholson O-NY
- Uri Tracy O-NY
- Peter Buell Porter O-NY
- Jeremiah Morrow O-OH
- John Porter O-PA
- William Anderson O-PA
- John Ross O-PA
- Matthias Richards O-PA
- David Bard O-PA
- Robert Whitehill O-PA
- George Smith O-PA
- William Crawford O-PA
- John Rea O-PA
- William Findley O-PA
- Aaron Lyle O-PA
- Robert Marion O-SC
- William Butler O-SC
- Robert Witherspoon O-SC
- John Taylor O-SC
- Joseph Calhoun O-SC
- Thomas Moore O-SC
- Lemuel James Alston O-SC
- John Rhea O-TN
- John George Jackson O-VA
- John Smith O-VA
- Jacob Swoope O-VA
- James Breckinridge O-VA
- John Love O-VA
- John Roane O-VA
- William Armisted Burwell O-VA
- Thomas Gholson Jr. O-VA
- Peterson Goodwyn O-VA
- Thomas Newton Jr. O-VA
- Samuel Shaw O-VT
Did not vote
- Ebenezer Huntington O-CT
- John Davenport O-CT
- Jonathan Ogden Moseley O-CT
- Samuel Whittlesey Dana O-CT
- Timothy Pitkin O-CT
- Nicholas Van Dyke O-DE
- Dennis Smelt O-GA
- George Michael Troup O-GA
- William Taylor Barry O-KY
- Edward St. Loe Livermore O-MA
- Joseph Bradley Varnum O-MA
- William Ely O-MA
- Charles Turner Jr. O-MA
- William Baylies O-MA
- Jabez Upham O-MA
- Joseph Allen O-MA
- Abijah Bigelow O-MA
- Ezekiel Whitman O-MA
- Orchard Cook O-MA
- Samuel Ringgold O-MD
- Alexander Mckim O-MD
- Nicholas Ruxton Moore O-MD
- Robert Wright O-MD
- Charles Goldsborough O-MD
- James Wilson O-NH
- William Hale O-NH
- John Anderson Scudder O-NJ
- William Helms O-NJ
- Gurdon Saltonstall Mumford O-NY
- Samuel Latham Mitchill O-NY
- Erastus Root O-NY
- Adam Seybert O-PA
- Benjamin Say O-PA
- Robert Brown O-PA
- John Smilie O-PA
- Elisha Reynolds Potter O-RI
- Richard Jackson Jr. O-RI
- Langdon Cheves O-SC
- Richard Winn O-SC
- Robert Weakley O-TN
- William Mckinley O-VA
- David Shepherd Garland O-VA
- Wilson Cary Nicholas O-VA
- John Clopton O-VA
- Jonathan Hatch Hubbard O-VT
- Martin Chittenden O-VT
Other votes
From Voteview roll call records.
Cite or embed this page
Capitol Receipts, “To amend the resolution to appoint…: House Vote, May 23, 1809,” https://www.capitolreceipts.com/vote/11-H-1/to-amend-the-resolution-to-appoint-committees-by-adding (accessed 2026-10-14).